A retrospective BNG appeal in Wakefield has removed two biodiversity conditions from planning permission for an agricultural feed store. Inspector J Smith allowed the appeal at Chevet Levels Farm on 19 November 2026, finding that statutory biodiversity net gain requirements had not been commenced for the retrospective planning permission involved.
The appeal, reference 6010809, concerned a livestock feed storage building constructed to dimensions different from those covered by an earlier agricultural prior notification. Wakefield Council subsequently granted retrospective permission under section 73A of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 but attached conditions demanding a Biodiversity Gain Plan and a separate Biodiversity Retention and Enhancement Scheme.
The retrospective BNG appeal is important for applicants and councils because the Inspector distinguished a development that is expressly exempt from the statutory regime from development to which the relevant law has never been brought into force. The distinction resolved the appeal, although it does not remove separate legal duties to address genuine ecological harm.
Why the retrospective BNG appeal arose
Chevet Levels Farm had first obtained approval through an agricultural prior notification, reference 23/02062/AGR. The constructed building did not match the approved dimensions. A subsequent full application, reference 24/02256/FUL, regularised the feed store retrospectively, but the council imposed two biodiversity conditions on the permission granted in March 2025. The appellant, Richard Tucker of A Tucker & Son Ltd, then sought to remove those conditions through application 24/02256/S7301.
Condition 2 required a Biodiversity Gain Plan containing information about the existing and proposed habitat value, any off-site gains and potential statutory credits. Condition 3 required a scheme covering habitat creation, grassland establishment, protection from public access, nesting features and bat roosts, with an implementation and maintenance programme. The council refused to remove them, arguing that doing so would fail to secure measurable biodiversity improvements and address ecological harm.
The Inspector had to decide whether these requirements were lawfully and necessarily imposed in the particular circumstances. This was not an appeal about whether wildlife deserves protection, nor a determination that agricultural development can ignore ecological considerations. It concerned the statutory basis for two specific planning conditions on an existing building.
Statutory BNG was not commenced for section 73A
The decisive issue in the retrospective BNG appeal was the scope of the Environment Act 2021 (Commencement No. 8 and Transitional Provisions) Regulations 2024. Regulation 2(2) brings relevant biodiversity gain provisions into force for certain permissions under Part 3 of the 1990 Act, while expressly excluding development to which section 73A applies. Section 73A is the route allowing planning permission to be granted for development already carried out.
Wakefield had argued that retrospective permissions do not appear in the separate Biodiversity Gain Requirements Regulations 2024 list of formal exemptions. The Inspector found that this was not the correct starting point. The question was not whether retrospective development had been placed into the exemptions list, but whether the statutory requirements had ever applied to it in the first place.
In the decision, Inspector Smith explained that the relevant provisions “were never commenced for development authorised under Section 73A”. This is the pivotal distinction. A requirement that has not been brought into force for a category of permission cannot be imposed simply by saying that the category is absent from a later list of exemptions.
The Inspector’s reading is consistent with the Government’s Planning Practice Guidance on biodiversity net gain, which states that mandatory BNG does not apply to retrospective planning permissions made under section 73A. That guidance and the commencement provisions should be checked before drafting biodiversity requirements for any retrospective application. It is also important not to conflate section 73A retrospective permission with all applications to vary conditions under section 73, for which separate transitional rules can matter.
Could local planning policy still require a gain?
The retrospective BNG appeal did not stop at the commencement regulations. The council also relied on Wakefield District Local Plan policies LP51 and LP56. The Inspector examined whether those policies supported retaining the biodiversity conditions independently of the statutory regime, rather than assuming that any local biodiversity reference justified a ten per cent gain.
Policy LP51(2)(c) concerns biodiversity gain in the context of development affecting particularly sensitive habitats and designated assets. The Inspector found no evidence of harm to ancient woodland, veteran trees, irreplaceable habitats or a regionally designated site that would bring the scheme within the relevant policy context. Policy LP56 addresses retention and enhancement of ecological and landscape features more generally, but its reference to meeting BNG requirements did not, on the evidence, establish a separate need for the disputed conditions.
The August 2026 National Planning Policy Framework also influenced the Inspector’s assessment. Policies N1(2) and N2(3), as quoted in the decision, restrict local standards going beyond statutory biodiversity net gain, including their application to exempt development. The Inspector reasoned that the same approach was appropriate where statutory provisions had never been commenced for the permission type. That was an interpretation applied to the particular local policy arguments, not a ruling that all ecological planning conditions are prohibited.
Two conditions removed, but not every issue resolved
The Inspector concluded that Conditions 2 and 3 were unnecessary for the retrospective permission and allowed the retrospective BNG appeal. The new permission retains an amended condition identifying the approved drawings and documents, but does not require the two biodiversity schemes. The decision does not specify that any ecological work already undertaken must be removed, nor does it grant general immunity from wildlife legislation or legitimate habitat mitigation requirements.
The council had separately raised questions about hardstanding on the farm which might differ from earlier approved drawings. The Inspector expressly left those questions outside the scope of this appeal. The landowner and council must resolve them separately, including through enforcement powers if justified. That boundary matters: success on a section 73A biodiversity condition does not retrospectively authorise every unauthorised operation on the wider site.
A separate application for appeal costs was refused. The Inspector considered that the disagreement involved a legally complex distinction between formal exemptions and provisions not yet commenced. Although the council’s ultimate legal interpretation was rejected, its behaviour was not found to be unreasonable so as to justify an award of costs. An allowed appeal and a successful costs application are different tests.
What applicants and councils can take from the decision
The practical lesson from the retrospective BNG appeal is to establish the actual legal consent route before applying the statutory biodiversity gain condition. For applicants, the description of development, dates, and whether section 73A genuinely applies should be evidenced carefully. A retrospective label alone does not settle every legal point. For councils, ecology conditions should identify the policy or statutory basis and demonstrate why the particular requirement is necessary for the development.
Our biodiversity net gain guide covers the statutory framework, while the retrospective planning permission guide explains the section 73A route. These are different parts of the analysis and should be read together where a completed building is being regularised.
The retrospective BNG appeal is reported in the Planning Inspectorate’s appeal record. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase. The cited commencement regulation and guidance provide a clear starting point for checking whether mandatory BNG applies, while any separate ecology requirements still need their own evidence and justification.


0 Comments