Permission in principle has been granted on appeal for up to six homes on grey belt land at Stourton in South Staffordshire. Inspector K Townend allowed the proposal on 19 November 2026, despite its location outside the settlement boundary and some harm to nearby designated heritage assets.
The decision concerns land west of Prestwood Road beside the Stourbridge and Staffordshire and Worcestershire canals. Appeal 6012851 overturns South Staffordshire District Council’s refusal of application 26/00416/PIP. It establishes the suitability of the location, residential use and amount of development, but does not approve house designs or grant permission to begin building.
The permission in principle decision is notable for two reasons. The Inspector treated the site as grey belt under the August 2026 National Planning Policy Framework, while accepting that the Framework’s Golden Rules would be relevant even though the proposed six homes were below the threshold for major development under the separate permission in principle legislation.
Permission in principle does not approve a detailed scheme
The statutory permission in principle route has two stages. At the first stage, the decision-maker considers only location, land use and the amount of development. Layout, appearance, scale, access arrangements and other detailed matters fall to a subsequent technical details consent application. Plans submitted with this appeal were therefore treated as indicative rather than final.
There is an important size distinction. Under the relevant permission in principle order, the route is unavailable for development that meets its major development thresholds, including ten or more homes, at least 1,000 square metres of floorspace or a site of one hectare or more. This particular site was below one hectare and involved no more than six dwellings.
The Inspector also explained that planning conditions cannot be imposed on a grant of permission in principle. That does not remove control over what might eventually be built. Technical details consent will have to deal with the necessary design, ecology, trees, biodiversity and infrastructure issues before development can lawfully proceed.
Why the Stourton land qualified as grey belt
The site is agricultural land outside the development boundary of Stourton, with canals along two sides. It sits opposite existing homes and close to other buildings. The Council’s May 2026 Green Belt appraisal was common ground on the point that this particular site did not strongly contribute to the relevant Green Belt purposes in national policy.
The Inspector then considered more than the site’s individual grey belt status. Although new buildings would amount to encroachment into open countryside, the position next to housing and the enclosing canals, hedges and trees meant the proposal would not fundamentally undermine the purposes of the remaining Green Belt across the plan area. This met the first limb of the national policy exception.
A further requirement was demonstrable unmet housing need. South Staffordshire Council accepted that it could not show a five-year housing land supply. The Inspector recorded the Council’s figure as just 0.87 years. That shortage satisfied the unmet need part of the grey belt test and gave substantial weight to delivering additional homes. Our housing land supply guide explains why the calculation can affect planning decisions.
The transport test required more than a connectivity score
Grey belt development under policy GB7 also needs to be in a sustainable location. Stourton has limited everyday facilities and the local development plan does not promote significant new housing there. However, the Inspector found usable walking routes to a small range of local services, bus stops within walking distance and opportunities to cycle towards Stourbridge.
National policy requires consideration of the Department for Transport’s Connectivity Tool alongside other quantitative and qualitative evidence. The appellant’s figures placed Stourton within the top 30 per cent of villages nationally for connectivity. That was useful evidence, but the Inspector made clear that the tool could not determine sustainability on its own.
The permission in principle appeal succeeded on accessibility because the combination of local facilities, bus services and cycling opportunities gave future occupiers a genuine choice of travel modes. A narrow or overgrown stretch of pavement did not, on the evidence, make the location unsustainable. This was a reasoned site-specific assessment, not an automatic approval for any rural village.
Golden Rules could be addressed at technical details stage
The most useful point may be how the Inspector handled the Green Belt Golden Rules. Although six homes on this site were not major development for the permission in principle statutory route, the site exceeded half a hectare and therefore met the separate major development definition used in the Framework. Inspector Townend explained that the Golden Rules are engaged as a material consideration
when assessing whether the proposal was suitable.
Those rules concern affordable housing, necessary infrastructure improvements and publicly accessible green space. The Inspector recognised that an enforceable planning obligation would be needed to secure the relevant contributions, but the precise obligations were not for determination at this first stage. It remained possible to comply when technical details consent was sought.
This does not mean that the Golden Rules have been waived or that a developer has an unconditional entitlement to technical details consent. The decision shows that a permission in principle application may establish the principle of a grey belt housing scheme while reserving the detailed evidence and legal obligations for the subsequent process. Our Green Belt and grey belt guidance discusses the different national policy exceptions.
Heritage harm was outweighed by housing benefits
Nearby heritage assets were a genuine constraint. The site lies near Grade II listed Stourton Castle, listed canal structures and the Staffordshire and Worcestershire Canal and Stourbridge Canal Conservation Areas. Building homes on currently open land would affect the rural setting of Stourton Castle and the settings of both conservation areas, although the Inspector found that the significance of the listed locks and tollbridge would not be harmed. The Inspector found limited harm to the significance of the castle and conservation areas, while giving that harm the considerable importance required by legislation.
That heritage harm was balanced against the substantial housing benefit in a district with a severe supply shortfall. The Inspector concluded that the public benefits outweighed the limited harm, taking account of the surrounding housing, intervening land and scope for careful landscaping. This is not a finding that heritage considerations can be deferred without assessment merely because permission in principle is sought.
The decision also afforded very limited weight to an older local Green Belt policy where its listed exceptions were materially narrower than those in the 2026 Framework. The emerging local plan received moderate weight, but neither displaced the national grey belt exception established on the evidence of this case.
What the decision changes and what remains to prove
For landowners considering permission in principle, the Stourton decision reinforces the need to separate the principle of development from technical matters. A proposal may be acceptable for its location, use and number of homes while still requiring substantial work on biodiversity net gain, heritage-sensitive design, landscaping, drainage, access and planning obligations. Later approval is not automatic.
The appeal was allowed on 19 November 2026 under reference 6012851. The Planning Inspectorate appeal record identifies the decision. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase. Its central lesson is that the two separate definitions of major development must not be conflated, particularly when grey belt Golden Rules are engaged.


0 Comments