Skip to content
Planning Geek logo

Planning consultancyBacked by the UK's leading planning resource

PLANNING NEWS

Caravan LDC appeal fails over unrestricted use

Somerset's caravan certificate appeal fails because evidence did not establish the claimed unrestricted use beyond an existing seasonal camping site.

The caravan LDC appeal at Home Farm near Carhampton in Somerset has been dismissed after an Inspector found that the owner had not proved the nature and scale of the use he wanted certified. An earlier certificate allowed a seasonal touring caravan and tent site, but the new application sought much wider flexibility over the caravans on the land.

Inspector M P Howell issued the decision on 19 November 2026 in appeal APP/E3335/X/25/3372705. Somerset Council had refused a certificate of lawful existing use for caravans of unrestricted size and type, potentially remaining on the site throughout the year while being occupied only between April and October.

The caravan LDC appeal matters well beyond this farm. It demonstrates the difference between a certificate describing a particular lawful use and a planning permission that may be interpreted by reference to its operative conditions. It also shows why a hypothetical argument about what a caravan site might lawfully accommodate is no substitute for evidence about what is actually happening on the land.

What the existing caravan certificate actually covered

The earlier lawful development certificate, issued on 22 March 2023, described camping and caravanning for 21 touring caravans and 26 tents between 1 April and 31 October each year. It also identified a separate area for car boot fairs in accordance with an earlier planning permission. That was the established lawful baseline against which the Inspector had to assess the new application.

The owner argued that the earlier certificate did not rule out other types of caravan, impose an absolute ceiling on their number, or prohibit caravans being left on the site outside the seasonal occupation period. In effect, the owner wanted the lawful use to be understood more broadly than the precise description in the 2023 certificate.

The new application sought recognition of the siting of caravans without restrictions on size or appearance, with occupation during the same April to October period. The main dispute in the caravan LDC appeal was not the planning merits of caravanning but whether the evidence proved that the existing use had the lawful character claimed.

Why the caravan LDC appeal failed on evidence

Section 191 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 allows a certificate for an existing use where the applicant demonstrates that it is lawful. The Inspector applied the balance of probabilities. The burden was on the applicant to provide clear enough facts to show what use was taking place and why that use did not amount to a breach of planning control.

The owner relied heavily on what the 2023 certificate might permit in theory. But the material before the Inspector did not establish with sufficient precision the number and type of caravans actually present, how they were arranged, how the site was operated or what facilities and physical works accompanied the use.

There was also insufficient evidence of what happened outside the permitted occupation season. The Inspector could not establish how many caravans remained on the land or how any stored units were arranged. No caravans or tents were visible during the site visit, so direct observation did not resolve those evidential gaps.

That distinction was decisive. The Inspector was not making a blanket ruling that every alteration to the mix or number of caravans must be a material change of use. The decision was narrower: without knowing the actual existing use with sufficient precision, there was no reliable basis for comparing it with the 2023 lawful baseline.

Inspector Howell concluded that the applicant had not shown that the existing use was lawful and wrote that he had “failed to discharge the necessary burden of proof”. The caravan LDC appeal was therefore dismissed. The stated commencement date of 1 January 2025 also meant the use had not persisted long enough to acquire immunity through the passage of time.

A description in an LDC is not a general permission

The Inspector distinguished an existing lawful development certificate from a planning permission. A certificate records the use or development demonstrated to be lawful on the relevant facts. It does not automatically authorise any other version of that use simply because the activity could broadly be described as caravanning.

The appellant invoked section 55(2)(f), concerning changes between purposes within the same use class. But the Inspector explained that the 2023 certificate did not grant a general unrestricted use-class permission. It certified a specifically described seasonal camping and caravanning use. That description could not simply be stretched into a different certified use without establishing the actual facts.

The owner also relied on court authorities about limitations in planning permissions, including I’m Your Man Ltd v Secretary of State for the Environment. That High Court case concerned the role of conditions in restricting a planning permission. The Inspector distinguished those authorities because this was an LDC application about an existing use, not the interpretation of a new planning permission.

This aspect of the caravan LDC appeal is particularly important for owners of established caravan and camping sites. A certificate describing touring caravans, tent numbers and a defined period cannot safely be assumed to cover additional static caravans, other arrangements or year-round siting without evaluating the character and actual operation of the use.

What evidence would have been needed?

The Inspector identified the relevant factual questions rather than giving an exhaustive checklist. They included the numbers and types of caravans and tents, their location and arrangement, facilities, any operational development, the scale of activities during the occupation season and the extent of caravan presence outside that season.

A properly evidenced application could address those matters through dated photographs, site plans, site-management records and a clear account of how the land has actually been used. Such documents would still have to be accurate and consistent. They would allow the authority, and any Inspector on appeal, to compare the actual use with the lawful baseline rather than speculate about what could occur.

The separate question whether a variation amounts to a material change of use would then be a matter of fact and degree. Proving that caravans have been on a site is not necessarily the same as proving an unrestricted caravan-site use. The precise certificate sought must match the use that the evidence establishes.

Planning Geek’s guide to caravan lawful development certificates explains the evidential approach, while its caravan parks planning permission guide discusses changes and extensions to established sites.

The outcome and wider lesson

The appeal was dismissed, leaving the council’s refusal of the new certificate in place. That does not revoke the 2023 certificate or establish that every conceivable alteration to the site would require permission. It means only that the broader existing use put forward in this particular application had not been demonstrated to be lawful.

The caravan LDC appeal serves as a warning against drafting a certificate application in terms wider than the proven use. A precise evidence trail, an accurate plan and a clear comparison with the existing certificate are likely to be more useful than arguments based on the absence of an express prohibition in an older document.

The underlying Planning Inspectorate appeal record provides the official reference. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Affected by this story, or spotted something we should check? Report an issue with this article

Planning news by email

Get the latest Planning Geek stories in one daily digest.

Finding Planning Geek useful?
Buy Ian a coffee to say thanks

Media enquiries

Journalist, broadcaster or producer? Need a quick comment on a planning story, policy change or decision?

Request a comment →

YouTube

Planning Geek on YouTube

Watch Ian explain permitted development, use classes, planning applications and current planning changes.

Watch on YouTube

Latest planning news

Edinburgh appeal allows New Town Quarter scheme

Edinburgh appeal allows New Town Quarter scheme

A Scottish reporter has allowed Edinburgh’s New Town Quarter appeal, unlocking 315 homes, student accommodation and commercial space after legal obligations were completed.

Transport orders gain heritage consent

Transport orders gain heritage consent

New transport order powers commenced on 20 November, allowing conditional deemed heritage consent for qualifying schemes in England and Wales.