A Coundon housing appeal has secured outline permission for up to 156 homes on farmland north of the County Durham settlement, despite an Inspector accepting that the scheme would harm countryside views and conflict with parts of the adopted local plan.
Inspector Carla Livingstone allowed the appeal by Partner Construction Ltd on 18 November 2026 after a hearing in September. Durham County Council had refused outline permission for land west of Westerton Road, where an amended scheme would retain public footpaths and provide a substantial area of open space.
The Coundon housing appeal shows how the revised August 2026 National Planning Policy Framework can shift the planning balance where a council cannot demonstrate five years of deliverable housing land. The Inspector accepted landscape harm but found that the benefits of the development were not substantially outweighed by the adverse effects.
The land and the harm to views
The application sought outline permission for up to 156 homes with all matters reserved except access. Two junctions from Westerton Road would provide access, while housing would principally occupy the eastern part of a 10.58-hectare site. Land to the north and west would provide public open space and a sustainable drainage pond.
This was not a finding that the countryside had little landscape value. Westerton Road is an elevated northern approach into Coundon, with open views towards the North Pennines. The Inspector recognised that the farmland made a positive contribution to the settlement’s setting, and its development would change how the edge of the village was experienced.
Approximately 20 existing homes would lose views across part of the open field and experience a moderate adverse visual effect. There would also be some harm to users of public rights of way FP70 and FP71. Nevertheless, the Inspector considered that open western views could still be experienced from retained routes and the new landscaped edge of the settlement, albeit with a reduced panorama.
The Coundon housing appeal therefore involved genuine conflict with County Durham Plan policies 6, 10 and 29 concerning unallocated countryside land, landscape character and important views. The Inspector also considered the harm moderate rather than significant or unacceptable. The conflict mattered, but it did not end the planning balance.
Why the five-year land supply changed the balance
The decisive policy context was the updated National Planning Policy Framework published on 17 August 2026. Both parties agreed that Durham could not demonstrate a five-year supply of deliverable housing sites. The Council’s figure was 3.92 years, while the appellant argued for 3.6 years. That difference did not affect the central point that there was an evidenced unmet housing need.
Policy S5(j) of the revised Framework supports development meeting an evidenced unmet need where it is physically well related to an existing settlement, is of an appropriate scale and can be accommodated by the available infrastructure. Both parties agreed that this site adjoined Coundon and could be accommodated with the secured infrastructure contributions.
The Coundon housing appeal turned in part on the mismatch between the Framework and the adopted County Durham Plan. Policies 6 and 10 did not expressly support the relevant type of housing development outside settlement boundaries where a five-year supply could not be demonstrated. The Inspector therefore gave less weight to the policy conflict, rather than ignoring it.
It also mattered that the 2026 Framework supports relevant development unless its benefits would be substantially outweighed by adverse effects. As the Inspector explained, the benefits of allowing the proposed development would not be substantially outweighed by adverse effects
. Planning Geek’s guide to the 2026 NPPF changes helps explain why that revised wording matters.
The Inspector rejected a suggestion that the outline status of the application meant the housing should receive less positive weight than a full application. The scheme would deliver both market and affordable homes, and that benefit attracted substantial weight. The earlier refusal of a full application for 156 dwellings was noted, but the Inspector emphasised that the current outline proposal was materially different.
Affordable housing, schools and public services
A completed section 106 agreement accompanied the Coundon housing appeal. It secured 10% affordable housing, together with financial contributions towards education, health and open space to address the additional demands of the development.
The specified sums included £194,447 towards early years provision, £724,757 for primary schools, £117,572 for special educational needs and disabilities education, £75,348 for NHS GP capacity and £72,587 for improvements to public open space. There were also provisions for monitoring on-site biodiversity net gain.
Inspector Livingstone found that the obligations satisfied the statutory tests for planning obligations: they were necessary, directly related to the development and fairly and reasonably related to its scale and kind. The agreement did not, on its own, erase landscape harm, but it helped demonstrate that local infrastructure could accommodate the proposal.
The development’s delivery of affordable housing and economic activity attracted positive weight. Planning Geek’s affordable housing planning guide explains the relationship between housing obligations, viability and the planning balance.
Biodiversity, footpaths and drainage safeguards
The Coundon housing appeal also included an updated biodiversity metric indicating gains significantly greater than the mandatory 10% benchmark. The Inspector gave moderate positive weight to that outcome, subject to a Biodiversity Gain Plan, habitat management and monitoring requirements.
The existing public footpaths through the site were to be retained, with the proposal adding accessible green space. The Inspector considered the extra public open space and associated improvements a benefit, despite the loss of some existing recreational land and changes to the character of the walks.
On flooding, the site lay in Flood Zone 1, although there were localised areas at risk of surface water flooding. Local residents and the Lead Local Flood Authority had raised drainage concerns, and the Council raised no objection subject to conditions. The Inspector concluded that appropriately designed and maintained drainage measures could avoid increased risk to the site or neighbouring properties. Flood-related conditions would need to be satisfied before the relevant development proceeded.
The 27 appeal conditions covered reserved matters, construction management, ecology, drainage, habitat management, highways, electric vehicle charging, public routes and provision for accessible homes. The decision remains an outline consent, not approval of every future layout or housing design detail. Planning Geek’s outline planning permission guide explains what still requires approval.
What the Coundon housing appeal means
The significance of the Coundon housing appeal is not that landscape objections can no longer defeat an edge-of-settlement housing scheme. The Inspector accepted an adverse effect on rural character, important views and local plan objectives, then assessed its weight against evidenced housing need, affordable housing, biodiversity, green space and the available mitigation.
The site’s grade 3b agricultural land was not classified as best and most versatile, and concerns about services, road safety and flooding did not establish additional reasons to dismiss the appeal on the evidence. The key distinction was between an acknowledged harm, which the Inspector weighed, and a harm sufficiently serious to outweigh the development’s benefits under the current policy test.
Appeal 6009574 concerns land west of Westerton Road in Coundon, application DM/25/03489/OUT. The Planning Inspectorate case record provides the official case route. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase. Quoted Planning Inspectorate decision material is Crown copyright, made available under the Open Government Licence.

0 Comments