Skip to content
Planning Geek logo

Planning consultancyBacked by the UK's leading planning resource

PLANNING NEWS

Section 106 contribution survives carbon hub closure

Court of Appeal rules a Peterborough carbon contribution remains enforceable despite the closure of an organisation named in its planning agreement.

by | 18th November 2026 14:08 | Case LawEnergySection 106

A section 106 contribution for off-site carbon mitigation remains enforceable despite the closure of a named specialist organisation, the Court of Appeal ruled on 17 November 2026. The case concerns a planning agreement associated with 295 homes in Peterborough.

The unanimous judgment in R (Morris Homes Ltd and another) v Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government [2026] EWCA Civ 1465 dismisses an appeal concerning 295 homes at Glebe Works in Peterborough.

For practitioners, the section 106 contribution ruling underlines that a planning obligation does not automatically fail when part of its intended delivery structure disappears. The court focused on the agreement’s continuing purpose, its objective criteria and its dispute-resolution machinery.

Why the section 106 contribution remained workable

Peterborough City Council granted permission in 2011 for 295 homes, a foodstore and associated infrastructure at Glebe Works, Glebe Court, Fletton. The site was one of two national Carbon Challenge sites and the original permission required the homes to achieve Level 6 of the Code for Sustainable Homes.

Morris Homes later obtained permission under section 73 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990. The revised condition removed the operational carbon element of the earlier requirement. A bilateral planning obligation dated 25 October 2013 instead required an Allowable Solutions Contribution to offset the carbon emissions generated on the site.

The section 106 contribution was calculated by formula and payable in stages before occupation of the 100th, 200th and 290th homes. The council would hold the money and spend it on qualifying projects in Peterborough.

The agreement envisaged approval of projects funded by the section 106 contribution through a board comprising representatives of the council, Morris Homes and Zero Carbon Hub Ltd. It also required projects to comply with the principles in a 2011 report and deliver carbon reductions at least equivalent to the relevant dwelling emissions.

Zero Carbon Hub ceased to exist

Zero Carbon Hub stopped trading in March 2016 and was dissolved in September 2024. No project board had been established. Morris Homes argued that the board could no longer be constituted in the form described by the agreement and that the contribution had therefore become unworkable.

The council demanded £383,268.09 in unpaid contributions in October 2017. Morris Homes applied in November 2023 to discharge the section 106 contribution, but the council refused the application in December of that year. Following an inspector’s decision dated 8 January 2025, the dispute proceeded to the Planning Court. This chronology matters: the litigation was not a fresh determination of the 2013 planning permission, but a challenge to whether an existing obligation could still fulfil a useful purpose after the delivery arrangements envisaged by the parties changed.

The inspector dismissed Morris Homes’ appeal under section 106B against the council’s refusal to discharge the obligation. The Planning Court dismissed a judicial review challenge in R (Morris Homes Ltd) v Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government [2025] EWHC 3236 (Admin).

The Court of Appeal has now upheld that result.

The court looked at the agreement as a whole

Lord Justice Lewison said the planning obligation was to be interpreted using the general principles that apply to contracts and other legal instruments, while recognising the public nature of planning documents.

The court rejected the suggestion that Zero Carbon Hub’s participation was indispensable. The council and Morris Homes remained able to identify and approve eligible projects. If they could not agree, the agreement contained an expert dispute-resolution procedure.

There were also objective limits on how the money could be used. Projects had to be within Peterborough, follow the stated principles and achieve the required level of carbon reduction.

Those provisions were sufficient to keep the section 106 contribution workable. The disappearance of one named organisation did not remove the essential bargain between the developer and the council.

A useful purpose still existed

The statutory issue under section 106A was whether the obligation continued to serve a useful purpose. The court held that it did.

The section 106 contribution still performed the role for which it had been negotiated: compensating for carbon emissions from homes that were no longer required to meet the original Level 6 condition. Changes to national policy and the failure of the anticipated national delivery arrangements to develop did not erase that local purpose.

Lewison LJ rejected the argument that this interpretation rewrote the agreement. The remaining provisions allowed the original promise to operate. He explained, at paragraph 67 of the judgment, that an unenforceability finding would let Morris Homes receive the benefit of the 2013 planning permission without providing a fixed sum for off-site carbon mitigation.

The court also dismissed a separate challenge to the inspector’s reasons. The decision letter had adequately addressed the central issues and explained why the contribution remained capable of administration.

What the judgment means for section 106 agreements

The section 106 contribution ruling does not mean that every planning obligation survives every later change. Whether an agreement remains enforceable depends on its own wording, purpose and machinery.

Where a named body disappears, the important questions include whether that body’s participation was essential, whether the obligation contains objective criteria and whether another mechanism can resolve disagreements. An express fallback or expert clause may be decisive.

The judgment also shows why section 106 drafting should anticipate institutional and policy change. Long-running developments may outlast government programmes, delivery bodies and technical standards.

Authorities and developers reviewing older obligations should therefore begin with the document as a whole rather than treating an obsolete name as a complete answer. Planning Geek’s guide to section 106 agreements explains the wider role of planning obligations and the routes for modification and discharge.

Separate High Court and Court of Appeal stages

The Court of Appeal decision is a separate authority from the 2025 Planning Court judgment. The appellate court adopted the first-instance account of the facts but dealt with the appeal on its own grounds.

The full appellate analysis is recorded in the Planning Geek Case Law entry for Morris Homes [2026] EWCA Civ 1465. The earlier Planning Court stage remains separately identified so that practitioners can follow the procedural history without treating one decision as a substitute for the other.

Practical points

  • Read the planning obligation as a whole before concluding that a later event has made it unworkable.
  • Identify the underlying planning purpose and the criteria governing how money or mitigation may be used.
  • Check whether the agreement contains a dispute-resolution or fallback mechanism.
  • Keep the section 106A useful-purpose test distinct from a request simply to renegotiate an inconvenient obligation.
  • Preserve the procedural distinction between the inspector’s decision, the High Court judgment and the Court of Appeal ruling.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Affected by this story, or spotted something we should check? Report an issue with this article

Planning news by email

Get the latest Planning Geek stories in one daily digest.

Finding Planning Geek useful?
Buy Ian a coffee to say thanks

Media enquiries

Journalist, broadcaster or producer? Need a quick comment on a planning story, policy change or decision?

Request a comment →

YouTube

Planning Geek on YouTube

Watch Ian explain permitted development, use classes, planning applications and current planning changes.

Watch on YouTube

Latest planning news