Horsham District Council has won a Cowfold housing appeal against nine proposed homes on Eastlands Lane, despite being unable to demonstrate a five-year supply of housing land. Planning Inspector Claire Coles dismissed the appeal on 4 November 2026 after finding that the development would sit awkwardly outside the village and harm its rural character.
The application, DC/26/0472, came from Eastlands Farm Ltd and Hunter Developments Ltd. It proposed nine dwellings on two separate parcels north of Eastlands Lane, with parking, carports, garages and landscaping. The council refused permission, and the applicants appealed under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990.
The Cowfold housing appeal is an early example of how the August 2026 National Planning Policy Framework is being applied to sites outside settlement boundaries. A housing shortfall helped the proposal, but it did not remove the need to satisfy the detailed location and design tests in national Policy S5.
Why the Cowfold housing appeal failed under Policy S5
The proposal was not a straightforward gap between houses. Seven homes were planned for the eastern parcel, where the Inspector considered there was enough built development to either side for that part to amount to limited infilling. Two further homes would occupy the western parcel, which was physically separate from the groups of houses around it.
National Policy S5(1)(e) supports limited infilling within groups of houses outside settlements. The Inspector held that the eastern parcel could meet that description, but the nine-home scheme had to be considered as a whole. Because the western parcel could not be described as infill between groups of houses, the complete development did not fall within that policy route.
The Cowfold housing appeal also tested Policy S5(1)(j). This gives a potential route for development meeting evidenced unmet housing need, provided it is physically well related to an existing settlement and of a scale that infrastructure can accommodate. The Inspector accepted that the infrastructure could accommodate the nine homes, but rejected the physical relationship with the village.
A substantial belt of woodland separated the western parcel from Cowfold’s built-up area boundary. Although one corner of that parcel came close to the boundary, the Inspector found no meaningful visual connection with the settlement and did not regard the development as a natural extension of the village.
This is the distinction our guide to building outside a settlement boundary explores. A site near a village is not necessarily physically well related to it. The relationship between the proposed buildings, existing houses, roads and intervening landscape can be as important as the distance to the boundary.
Housing land supply did not secure permission
Horsham could not demonstrate a five-year supply of deliverable housing sites. Under the revised Framework that shortfall can establish an unmet housing need for Policy S5(1)(j), but it does not displace the policy’s other requirements. A development which fails the physical-relationship test cannot rely on the housing supply deficit to qualify automatically.
The Inspector did give real weight to delivering additional homes. Policy HO7 requires substantial weight to be given to benefits meeting evidenced accommodation needs. In the final balance, however, the Inspector concluded that nine dwellings would make only a small contribution to the district-wide shortfall and assigned the housing benefit moderate weight.
The Cowfold housing appeal therefore highlights a practical difference from treating housing land supply as a simple overriding consideration. The proposal fell outside the specified categories in S5(1), so the more demanding exceptional-circumstances test in Policy S5(4) applied. That required benefits substantially to outweigh the adverse effects, including effects on countryside character.
For the wider approach to supply calculations and their current decision-making consequences, see our updated guide to five-year housing land supply. The revised national policy is also set out in our explanation of the National Planning Policy Framework.
The western parcel changed the landscape assessment
The design findings were closely tied to the layout of the two parcels. The Inspector regarded the proposed homes on the eastern part as appropriately scaled infill, but thought the western homes would sit detached from the existing pattern of development, appearing as a new pocket of buildings in a green field.
Inspector Coles described the western element as an “uncharacteristic pocket of development” which would not integrate with or enhance its surroundings.
A landscaping undertaking promised to retain and manage existing planting and woodland while adding further soft landscaping. The Inspector found that those measures would not offset the harm to the open and undeveloped character of the site. The proposal conflicted with local design policies and the new national decision-making Policy DP3.
In the Cowfold housing appeal, this meant that the objections were not merely about whether the land sat on the correct side of a line. The broader problem was the visual and spatial break between the village and the western parcel, together with a layout which failed to respond to its countryside context.
A recent neighbourhood plan received limited weight
Cowfold’s neighbourhood plan had been adopted in November 2025 and contained housing allocations. That brought Policy S6 of the 2026 Framework into consideration, because it offers particular protection to qualifying recent neighbourhood plans against certain housing proposals.
Nevertheless, the Inspector found that the neighbourhood plan’s housing requirement rested on a needs assessment from May 2019. With national policy having changed and Horsham’s housing land shortfall continuing, that evidence was considered too dated to justify significant weight. Conflict with the neighbourhood plan’s housing policies therefore received limited weight.
That was not the reason the Cowfold housing appeal failed. Even allowing limited weight to the neighbourhood plan conflict, the Inspector remained concerned about the location and design of the whole development. The council’s older 2015 district plan policies were not discounted just because of their age; their approach to settlement location and design was considered consistent with the relevant 2026 national policy.
Heritage and ecology were not decisive
A listed building, Eastlands Farm, lies to the south-east. Although the council’s conservation officer had expressed concern about effects on its wider setting, the Inspector concluded that the proposed development would make no meaningful contribution to that setting and would have a neutral impact on the building’s heritage significance.
The site also raised questions about a public right of way, local green spaces and nearby protected trees. The appellants showed that the right of way lay outside the application boundary and that the site did not include one of the local green spaces, and the Inspector was not given substantive evidence that works to Eastlands Lane would harm the other. A NatureSpace great crested newt licensing certificate and proposed planning obligation were noted, but not taken further once the location and design objections had proved decisive.
There was also a nearby council approval for 101 dwellings, application DC/25/1922, outside the settlement boundary. The Inspector distinguished that scheme because it was separated from the boundary only by a road, with a much clearer physical and visual relationship to the settlement. It was not treated as a direct precedent for this different site.
What the Cowfold housing appeal means for applicants
The key lesson is to test a multi-parcel housing site as a single scheme, not just identify the strongest part of it. An eastern parcel that can plausibly count as infill does not necessarily carry a disconnected western parcel into the same favourable national policy category.
It is equally important to distinguish a housing supply shortfall from the other limbs of Policy S5. Evidence of unmet need may be clear, yet the proposed housing must still be physically well related to an existing settlement where that requirement applies. An intervening wood or an unfamiliar pattern of development can defeat that argument.
The Cowfold housing appeal also shows why a dated housing requirement in a recent neighbourhood plan may attract less weight than its adoption date suggests. At the same time, housing benefits and arguments about that evidence will not overcome a convincing design and landscape objection without a stronger site-specific case.
Contemporaneous local reporting recorded that planning officers refused the application on built-up area and landscape grounds.
The Planning Inspectorate appeal record is for reference 6011338. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase.

0 Comments