A fuel depot appeal in Cambridge has allowed 12 homes beside a working tanker depot, but only after an Inspector required stronger noise safeguards than the developer had proposed. Inspector M Cryan granted permission on 20 November 2026 for housing at Ditton Walk, including three affordable rented homes.
The vacant site, formerly used as an ambulance station and adult training centre, adjoins Certas Energy’s fuel depot. Operations are busiest in the early morning, when tanker engines, pumps, hoses and other activities can be clearly heard from the proposed housing site. Cambridge City Council refused the scheme principally because of the risks to future residents and the existing business.
The fuel depot appeal is an important test of the agent of change principle. The Inspector did not accept the applicant’s original mitigation as adequate, yet concluded that enforceable conditions could make the development acceptable without placing unreasonable restrictions on the depot’s operation.
Why the fuel depot appeal was allowed
The scheme at land adjoining 139 Ditton Walk, Cambridge, was submitted by This Land Ltd under application 23/04380/FUL. It provides 12 two, three and four-bedroom houses, with three affordable rented units secured by a section 106 agreement. The appeal site is part of the larger R5 residential allocation in Cambridge’s 2018 Local Plan, but the neighbouring western portion remains in use for fuel storage and distribution.
The council originally gave five reasons for refusing permission. At appeal it withdrew its objections relating to trees, pedestrian routes and cycle parking, considering that conditions could deal with those matters. Its remaining case concerned the effects of depot noise on future householders and the risk that complaints from the new residents could restrict an established industrial activity.
Inspector Cryan held a hearing in March and April 2026 and made a formal site visit at 5.30am on 16 April, timed to coincide with the depot’s busiest operating period. The Inspector found significant industrial noise during roughly 5am to 7.30am, including idling engines, low-frequency pump noise, metal impacts, air brakes and vehicle cleaning. The fuel depot is not subject to a planning condition limiting its hours, although other legal controls can still apply.
Open windows exposed a serious weakness
In this fuel depot appeal, the developer proposed a layered design with a 3.5 metre acoustic fence, building orientation, glazed openings facing away from the depot where possible and mechanical ventilation with heat recovery. Its acoustic consultants argued that the scheme would achieve the internal sound standards used in the design. The council disputed some assumptions about noise intensity, including the number of operating pumps and tanker movements.
A key concern was the reliance on bedroom windows being shut. The Inspector noted that achieving the proposed night-time noise target would depend on some or all windows being closed in 11 of the 12 homes, affecting 20 of the 40 bedrooms. Residents could not be expected always to keep openable windows closed, particularly at night, and low-frequency noise is more difficult to block with ordinary double glazing and an external fence.
The Inspector considered there was a considerable risk of future statutory nuisance complaints if the original design were built without firmer controls. That could undermine the agent of change principle and the protection of existing businesses, which place responsibility on incoming sensitive development to accommodate existing lawful noise-generating uses.
Stricter conditions made the difference
The applicant and council could not agree a single set of noise conditions after the hearing. The applicant’s version would allow openable windows and permitted the internal targets to be met with windows shut if necessary. The council sought a stricter approach, including non-openable windows where necessary, specific assessment of low-frequency noise and a defined background noise reference.
Inspector Cryan preferred the council’s more robust approach, writing that “high standards of mitigation are required” and found it necessary to limit window opening where compliance could not otherwise be demonstrated. The Inspector rejected the suggestion that all rooms could be required to meet noise limits regardless of whether windows were open, because that would be physically impossible.
The fuel depot appeal was therefore not a finding that proximity to industry can simply be solved by specifying acoustic glazing. Detailed acoustic design, validation before occupation, mechanical ventilation, an effective boundary barrier and lasting restrictions on alterations were integral to the permission. The decision’s extensive condition schedule also includes noise-insulation requirements, a 3.5 metre acoustic fence, contamination controls and ecological measures.
Revised acoustic fence accepted at appeal
During the application the developer had proposed increasing the acoustic fence from 2.5 metres to 3.5 metres. Cambridge City Council had not accepted the amendment because it considered the changes insufficient to resolve the noise objections. At the appeal, the Inspector nevertheless assessed the taller fence, after considering whether doing so would be procedurally fair.
In reaching that decision, the Inspector referred to the Holborn Studios judgment and the established Wheatcroft approach to amendments. The Inspector found the proposal was not fundamentally changed and interested parties had opportunities to comment, including through a specific neighbour consultation and the hearing. That did not make all revisions on appeal acceptable; it depended on the absence of procedural or substantive unfairness.
Affordable housing and the wider benefits
The fuel depot appeal also dealt with the August 2026 National Planning Policy Framework. The Inspector gave substantial weight to housing delivery, including the three affordable rented homes, and the reuse of vacant land, and concluded that the housing would comply with relevant local policies once robust noise conditions were imposed. It was not necessary to decide the detailed housing land supply and housing delivery arguments.
The section 106 agreement secures the affordable housing and contributions towards local open space, sports, community facilities, play provision, healthcare, education, libraries and waste facilities. The Inspector found the obligations met the statutory tests. Applications for costs were made by both the developer and Cambridge City Council, but the main appeal decision stated that those applications would be determined separately. Their outcomes should not be presumed.
This fuel depot appeal shows why developers must test a residential scheme against the actual operating pattern of adjoining businesses, not just a daytime acoustic average. Surveys, assumptions about windows, low-frequency sound and realistic enforceable mitigation can determine whether housing and employment uses will coexist. Our guidance on noise in planning applications explains the evidence and conditions that can matter.
Inspector M Cryan allowed appeal 6003093 on 20 November 2026, subject to conditions. The Planning Inspectorate appeal record identifies the case. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase.

0 Comments