Skip to content
Planning Geek logo

Planning consultancyBacked by the UK's leading planning resource

PLANNING NEWS

Listed coach house window enforcement upheld

Kent coach house remains within a listed rectory's historic curtilage despite separate ownership, with uPVC window enforcement upheld on appeal.

by | 20th November 2026 08:56 | AppealsEnforcement

A listed coach house in the Kent village of Offham remains protected as part of a neighbouring Grade II listed rectory despite changes to its ownership, physical boundaries and use. An Inspector has dismissed an appeal against a listed building enforcement notice requiring modern uPVC windows and doors to be removed from the former outbuilding.

Inspector AJ Steen issued the decision on 19 November 2026 in appeal APP/H2265/F/24/3341748. The appeal concerned Denvi House, formerly The Coach House, near The Old Rectory at Aldon Lane, West Malling. Tonbridge and Malling Borough Council had issued its notice in March 2024 after timber joinery shown on earlier listed building consent drawings was replaced with markedly different uPVC openings.

The listed coach house appeal is relevant to anyone buying, dividing or converting an old ancillary building. Separate ownership and new fencing do not automatically take a pre-1948 structure outside listed building control. The decision also shows why approval for converting a historic outbuilding does not necessarily authorise substantially different windows and doors.

Why was the listed coach house still protected?

Denvi House was historically a coach house serving The Old Rectory, an eighteenth-century building listed at Grade II. It later became separately owned and was the subject of permissions and listed building consent for conversion to a dwelling. The appellant argued that the outbuilding was no longer within the curtilage of the listed rectory and so should not be treated as part of a listed building.

The Inspector applied section 1(5) of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990, which can extend statutory protection to an object or structure within the curtilage of a listed building that has formed part of the land since before 1 July 1948. Whether a structure falls within that definition is a question of fact and degree, not something determined solely by current Land Registry ownership or a newly erected fence.

For the listed coach house, the historic relationship was particularly important. The former ancillary building stood close to The Old Rectory and had served it before the statutory cut-off date. The Inspector considered their layout, ownership and uses, including the construction of dividing fences and the sale of the coach house for conversion.

The Inspector accepted that those relationships had changed, but said that changes to the physical layout, ownership and use “have not altered the relationship sufficiently” to remove Denvi House from the rectory’s historic curtilage for the purpose of section 1(5). The fact that it was not individually listed did not prevent Denvi House being treated as a listed building through its relationship with The Old Rectory. The appellant’s first appeal ground therefore failed.

What work had been carried out?

The notice concerned replacement windows and doors across several elevations. The consented conversion drawings had retained the coach-house character through traditional timber detailing, arched openings and doors. Instead, modern uPVC units, including square casements and a glazed domestic-style entrance door, were installed. An additional opening was also formed in one elevation.

The listed coach house also had changes that altered the reading of its historic elevations. On one side, the former coach-house openings had been replaced by features associated with ordinary domestic accommodation. The Inspector contrasted that appearance with the approved drawings, which would have preserved more of the building’s original functional character.

The fact that a building is to become residential does not require its historic character to be erased. The earlier planning permission and listed building consent allowed a dwelling to be created while retaining important features. The Inspector considered the uPVC replacements substantially different from those already approved, both in material and in design.

How was heritage harm assessed?

The Inspector found that the changes produced a modern domestic appearance which compromised the former coach house’s contribution to the setting and significance of The Old Rectory. The harm was not simply the use of plastic rather than timber. The shape, positioning and arrangement of the openings changed the way the outbuilding was understood as part of the historic group.

In the listed coach house decision, the Inspector attached substantial weight to conserving designated heritage assets and considered the public benefits advanced for the works. The appellant referred to earlier dealings with the council about glazing and said the cost of replacing the work would be difficult. The Inspector did not consider those matters sufficient to outweigh the identified heritage harm.

A new dwelling was also put forward as a benefit. However, the building already had permission to become a dwelling using the approved joinery, so that housing benefit did not depend on retaining the unauthorised uPVC work. The Inspector concluded that the appeal seeking listed building consent for the replacements should also fail. Our guide to heritage significance and harm explains how these planning judgments are made.

What did the enforcement notice require?

Tonbridge and Malling’s listed building enforcement notice required the unauthorised openings to be removed and replaced with details approved under listed building consent 15/00539/LB, or restored to the previous configuration where specified. It also required the associated damage to the building’s fabric to be made good using appropriate matching materials, within the nine-month compliance period.

The Inspector made a narrow correction to the wording of one part of the alleged breach, reversing the order of two words. That typographical change did not affect the substance of the requirements or cause injustice to either side. Subject to that correction, the notice was upheld and listed building consent for retention of the works was refused.

The listed coach house ruling therefore should not be described as a partial success simply because one line of the notice was corrected. The substantive outcome was that the appellant lost both the challenge to the building’s listed status and the request for consent to retain the altered fenestration. Our listed building consent guide sets out the broader consent requirements.

What does the Offham appeal mean for owners?

A buyer of a converted barn, coach house, lodge or other historic ancillary building should not assume that a separate title, residential use or intervening fence means listed building controls have fallen away. The relevant history includes the building’s function before July 1948 and the physical, ownership and use relationships with the principal listed building. Each case still requires its own factual assessment.

Likewise, an approved conversion does not permit arbitrary substitutes for heritage details shown on approved drawings. The design of windows, doors, arch openings, materials and joinery can be central to preserving special architectural or historic interest. The listed coach house result underlines the importance of checking both the consent and its approved plans before replacement work begins.

There can also be a practical issue for purchasers who inherit works carried out by others. Listed building enforcement powers are concerned with the building and the unauthorised works, not simply whether the present owner knew that consent was needed. Anyone considering alterations should establish the building’s status and applicable consents rather than assume that modern residential occupation has settled the issue.

The decision, dated 19 November 2026, is recorded under APP/H2265/F/24/3341748. The Planning Inspectorate appeal record provides the official case reference. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase. The Inspector quotation is Planning Inspectorate material under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Affected by this story, or spotted something we should check? Report an issue with this article

Planning news by email

Get the latest Planning Geek stories in one daily digest.

Finding Planning Geek useful?
Buy Ian a coffee to say thanks

Media enquiries

Journalist, broadcaster or producer? Need a quick comment on a planning story, policy change or decision?

Request a comment →

YouTube

Planning Geek on YouTube

Watch Ian explain permitted development, use classes, planning applications and current planning changes.

Watch on YouTube

Latest planning news

Edinburgh appeal allows New Town Quarter scheme

Edinburgh appeal allows New Town Quarter scheme

A Scottish reporter has allowed Edinburgh’s New Town Quarter appeal, unlocking 315 homes, student accommodation and commercial space after legal obligations were completed.

Transport orders gain heritage consent

Transport orders gain heritage consent

New transport order powers commenced on 20 November, allowing conditional deemed heritage consent for qualifying schemes in England and Wales.