Skip to content
Planning Geek logo

Planning consultancyBacked by the UK's leading planning resource

PLANNING NEWS

Retrospective BNG appeal wins in Wakefield

Wakefield livestock-store conditions requiring biodiversity plans are removed after an Inspector finds statutory BNG was never commenced for retrospective permission.

A retrospective BNG appeal in Wakefield has succeeded after an Inspector found that two conditions requiring biodiversity plans were not necessary for an agricultural feed-store permission. The key issue was whether the statutory biodiversity net gain regime had ever been commenced for development already carried out.

Inspector J Smith issued the decision on 19 November 2026 concerning Chevet Levels Farm, where an agricultural building differed from an earlier prior approval. A subsequent retrospective permission had been granted subject to conditions for a Biodiversity Gain Plan and a Biodiversity Retention and Enhancement Plan. The council refused an application to remove them.

The retrospective BNG appeal is useful well beyond this particular farm because the Inspector addressed a distinction that can be missed in practice: retrospective section 73A permissions are not merely another category on an exemptions list. The relevant statutory gain provisions were never brought into force for them.

Why the retrospective BNG appeal arose

The building was first dealt with through agricultural prior notification, reference 23/02062/AGR. What was actually constructed differed in dimensions from the approved building, and the owner later sought retrospective planning permission under application 24/02256/FUL. Wakefield granted it in March 2025 but imposed conditions numbered 2 and 3 dealing with biodiversity gain and retention.

An application under section 73A of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990, reference 24/02256/S7301, sought permission without complying with those conditions. The council refused on the basis that removal would leave ecological harm unaddressed and would not secure a measurable biodiversity gain. That refusal brought the retrospective BNG appeal before the Planning Inspectorate.

The appellant argued that mandatory biodiversity net gain did not apply because the original permission was retrospective. The council pointed out that section 73A was not named as an explicit exemption in the Biodiversity Gain Requirements (Exemptions) Regulations 2024. On a superficial reading those positions may look irreconcilable, but the Inspector approached the commencement provisions rather than stopping at the exemption list.

Commencement matters more than the exemption list

The Inspector examined the Environment Act 2021 (Commencement No. 8 and Transitional Provisions) Regulations 2024, particularly regulation 2, alongside Schedule 7A to the 1990 Act. The Inspector’s explanation was that the regime was introduced only for the relevant categories of permission. For retrospective development authorised by section 73A, it was not brought into effect in the first place.

As the Inspector put it, “the relevant Biodiversity Net Gain provisions were never commenced”. That was the foundation of the Inspector’s reasoning, rather than treating a section 73A permission as an exemption that ought to appear by name in the 2024 exemptions regulations. The distinction is also reflected in the current government planning guidance on biodiversity net gain.

Planning Geek’s existing guidance on retrospective planning permission explains the section 73A route, and our separate biodiversity net gain guide covers the statutory starting point and exemptions. Neither should be read as meaning that any ecological impacts are automatically harmless or that all development can be described as retrospective.

Could local policies still require a biodiversity gain?

Wakefield also relied on its adopted Local Plan policies LP51 and LP56. The Inspector examined their scope and considered the newer national policy restrictions on local biodiversity standards. Policy LP51 addressed particularly sensitive habitats and sites, but there was no evidence before the Inspector of the specific harm to ancient woodland, veteran trees, irreplaceable habitats or a regionally designated site necessary to engage the cited limb of that policy.

The Inspector also considered national policies N1 and N2, which limit the ability of development plans to demand biodiversity gains beyond the statutory framework for categories outside that regime. The Inspector reasoned that the principle should encompass development for which the biodiversity provisions had not been commenced. That is a case-specific interpretation of the applicable policy, not an exemption from all nature conservation obligations.

The retrospective BNG appeal therefore resulted in a fresh planning permission without conditions 2 and 3. The Inspector kept a revised plans condition to identify the approved development, while removing the disputed biodiversity documentation from that condition. This was a targeted removal of unnecessary requirements, not a permission to undertake other unauthorised works.

Costs refused despite success on the main appeal

The appellant also sought a full award of costs against Wakefield. That application failed. Inspector Smith said the statutory relationship was sufficiently difficult that the council’s interpretation was not unreasonable, particularly as the appellant’s submissions had relied mainly on government guidance rather than directing officers to the decisive commencement provisions.

There was a further evidential weakness in the appellant’s suggestion that the site had a zero habitat baseline. A metric associated with an earlier returned application indicated 1.06 habitat units, and the appellant had not produced an updated calculation. The Inspector was therefore unwilling to conclude that the council acted unreasonably in its treatment of the ecological evidence or the development plan.

This part of the retrospective BNG appeal is worth remembering. Winning a planning appeal does not automatically mean the other side behaved unreasonably or caused wasted expense. A full costs application still has to satisfy its separate test, based on conduct and consequences, and the Inspector refused it here.

What the decision means for planning applications

The practical starting point is to identify exactly which permission is being sought and whether the works genuinely took place before the application. The legal distinction between section 73, section 73A and an ordinary prospective permission matters. The statutory biodiversity regime will not fall away just because an applicant labels a scheme retrospective or presents an amended condition application.

Where development is genuinely retrospective, applicants should set out both the commencement provisions and the scope of the relevant local policies, rather than simply citing a generic exemption. If a council requires a biodiversity condition, the decision should explain why that condition meets the usual tests of necessity and relevance. Our retrospective application guide gives a practical introduction to that first question.

A final caution is that the Inspector expressly left a separate hardstanding dispute unresolved. The appeal concerned the feed-store conditions, not whether other works matched approved drawings. Wakefield retained its ordinary enforcement powers in relation to matters outside the decision. The retrospective BNG appeal should therefore be understood as a decision about these particular conditions and this permission, not a blanket certificate that everything at the farm was lawful.

The appeal decision and separate costs decision were issued on 19 November 2026, and the appeal is recorded on the Planning Inspectorate’s appeal page. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Affected by this story, or spotted something we should check? Report an issue with this article

Planning news by email

Get the latest Planning Geek stories in one daily digest.

Finding Planning Geek useful?
Buy Ian a coffee to say thanks

Media enquiries

Journalist, broadcaster or producer? Need a quick comment on a planning story, policy change or decision?

Request a comment →

YouTube

Planning Geek on YouTube

Watch Ian explain permitted development, use classes, planning applications and current planning changes.

Watch on YouTube

Latest planning news

Edinburgh appeal allows New Town Quarter scheme

Edinburgh appeal allows New Town Quarter scheme

A Scottish reporter has allowed Edinburgh’s New Town Quarter appeal, unlocking 315 homes, student accommodation and commercial space after legal obligations were completed.

Transport orders gain heritage consent

Transport orders gain heritage consent

New transport order powers commenced on 20 November, allowing conditional deemed heritage consent for qualifying schemes in England and Wales.