Skip to content
Planning Geek logo

Planning consultancyBacked by the UK's leading planning resource

PLANNING NEWS

Rural leisure appeal fails on highways

Three farm barns proposed for sports and recreation fail at appeal over rural road safety and missing biodiversity information, despite acceptable Green Belt impacts.

A rural leisure appeal has been dismissed in South Gloucestershire after an Inspector found that converting three agricultural barns into commercial sports and recreation facilities would harm highway safety and lacked the required biodiversity evidence. The decision was issued on 19 November 2026 for buildings and land near Old Parish Lane at Dodington Ash.

Inspector Stuart Willis dismissed appeal 6010447 against South Gloucestershire Council’s refusal of application P25/02854/F. The assessment was not an automatic objection to recreational uses in the countryside. The Inspector accepted that the scheme would not be inappropriate development in the Green Belt and would not harm the adjoining historic landscape, but found serious shortcomings elsewhere.

The rural leisure appeal has an important practical lesson for landowners considering farm building diversification. Passing the Green Belt and heritage tests does not guarantee permission where transport evidence and biodiversity net gain information are inadequate. A separate application for a full award of appeal costs against the council was also refused.

Rural leisure appeal concerned three farm buildings

The proposal was to change the use of three barns from agriculture to commercial sports and recreation facilities, classified in the application as Use Class E. It also included related alterations and external areas. An external dog walking area on modified grassland formed part of the scheme, alongside items such as a small sauna, covered shelter, parking and access arrangements.

The site lies in open countryside within the Green Belt and near the Grade II* registered park and garden at Dodington House. It is also in the Cotswolds National Landscape setting. Those designations made the location sensitive, but the Inspector separated the effects on each asset rather than assuming that all rural leisure use was prohibited.

The rural leisure appeal is particularly relevant to businesses seeking to repurpose agricultural buildings. Planning Geek’s Use Class E guide explains why the precise proposed activity matters; Class E status does not itself confer permission for a material change from an agricultural use. Nor should the outcome be confused with a determination under the separate agricultural building permitted development rights in Class R.

Green Belt and heritage were not the reasons for dismissal

The Inspector accepted that the buildings were substantial and that the proposed alterations would not cause a disproportionate expansion. With landscape screening and the scale of the external works, the development would not be inappropriate in the Green Belt. This was an individual assessment of the works and use, not a general exemption for sports businesses.

The decision also explored the setting of the historic Dodington House park and garden, with its eighteenth and nineteenth century landscape design associations. The surrounding farmed landscape, roads and buildings contribute to that setting, yet the proposed alterations would remain largely within the existing agricultural building group, with mature planting limiting visibility.

Additional traffic and modest lighting were considered, but the Inspector found that the heritage significance of the registered park and garden would be preserved. The scenic beauty of the Cotswolds National Landscape would also be conserved. The rural leisure appeal therefore shows why neutral findings on sensitive designations must not be confused with a favourable overall planning balance.

Narrow lanes made extra car journeys unacceptable

The larger difficulty was the journey to the site. Surrounding lanes were narrow, sometimes steep, unlit and without pavements. Passing places existed, but some were informal, partly obstructed or outside the appellant’s control. There were also bends and gaps with limited forward visibility.

The Inspector recognised the existing farm traffic and other businesses in the area, but considered that the leisure facility would create a different and materially higher pattern of travel. Walking and cycling were unlikely choices for many users, while nearby public transport was limited. Car sharing was suggested, but there was no clear evidence of an enforceable arrangement.

Even though the road network could accommodate the additional vehicles in capacity terms, the increase in encounters between cars, larger vehicles, cyclists and pedestrians created an unacceptable safety risk. The Inspector gave substantial weight to highway safety and accessibility harm. The rural leisure appeal illustrates why a traffic statement should assess the real physical and operational conditions of rural lanes, not simply calculate whether there is spare capacity.

Biodiversity net gain information was missing

A separate difficulty was the use of an external dog walking area on more than 25 square metres of modified grassland. Although this involved little additional building work, the Inspector considered that the changed activity would affect habitat. No valid exemption from mandatory biodiversity net gain had been demonstrated.

The decision records that the necessary minimum biodiversity information had not been supplied, including a satisfactory account of the site’s pre-development habitat value. The Inspector therefore could not be satisfied that the statutory gain objective would be met. This failure attracted moderate weight against the proposal.

Crucially, the missing information was an application-stage problem rather than a minor detail that could be left to a later condition. The Inspector said “this cannot be dealt with by a separate condition”. Our biodiversity net gain guide sets out the statutory metric, current exemptions and the distinction between information required with an application and the subsequent gain plan. The rural leisure appeal demonstrates how seriously this omission can affect a decision.

Costs application failed as well

Andrew Gent also sought a full award of costs against South Gloucestershire Council. The application was considered in a separate decision, with the Inspector refusing the award. The conclusion was not that the council had succeeded on every individual planning issue. It was that the authority had given an evidence-based case for its refusal rather than acted unreasonably.

The appellant pointed to other schemes in the registered park and garden and disputed the council’s approach to evidence. The Inspector found that those schemes differed in nature, scale, location and planning balance, and that disagreement about the weight of evidence did not itself constitute unreasonable behaviour. The council was not obliged to accept every amendment to evidence during the application process.

The costs ruling is a useful distinction for anyone considering a rural leisure appeal. An authority can lose an argument about heritage and still reasonably defend its decision on transport or ecology. An award requires unreasonable behaviour causing unnecessary or wasted expense, not merely the appellant’s disagreement with the refusal. Our guide to appeal costs explains that threshold.

What rural diversification applicants should take from it

The Inspector gave limited positive weight to the economic, health and recreation benefits of the proposed facility. National policy support for rural leisure, tourism and community uses did not resolve why this particular location was needed, how users would reach it without private cars, or how their journeys could be made acceptably safe.

The rural leisure appeal therefore offers a practical sequence for future proposals. Check the lawful building and use class position first, then prove the intensity of the proposed activity, the safety of routes for all road users and any necessary habitat calculations. A good heritage statement cannot compensate for an unsupported transport case or missing mandatory BNG information.

Appeal 6010447 was dismissed on 19 November 2026, and the related costs application was refused. The Planning Inspectorate case page provides the official appeal record. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Affected by this story, or spotted something we should check? Report an issue with this article

Planning news by email

Get the latest Planning Geek stories in one daily digest.

Finding Planning Geek useful?
Buy Ian a coffee to say thanks

Media enquiries

Journalist, broadcaster or producer? Need a quick comment on a planning story, policy change or decision?

Request a comment →

YouTube

Planning Geek on YouTube

Watch Ian explain permitted development, use classes, planning applications and current planning changes.

Watch on YouTube

Latest planning news

Liverpool HMO appeal: full costs award

Liverpool HMO appeal: full costs award

An Inspector allows two Liverpool HMOs and awards full appeal costs after finding the council’s noise objections inadequately supported.