A Class Q appeal for six homes in an agricultural building near Ashley, North Northamptonshire, has been dismissed because the Inspector was not satisfied that 20 internal bedrooms would receive adequate natural daylight. The decision was issued on 19 November 2026 and concerned a large steel-framed barn off Medbourne Road.
Inspector Kate Williams dismissed appeal 6007859 against North Northamptonshire Council’s refusal of prior approval for Kim Berry’s proposal, application 25/01528/3QCOU. The scheme would have converted the existing barn into six four-bedroom houses. Although the building and proposed alterations were acceptable in principle, the missing daylight evidence proved decisive.
The Class Q appeal is particularly useful for anyone designing homes within deep agricultural buildings. The Inspector accepted the agricultural eligibility evidence, found the external appearance satisfactory and had no overriding highway objection. The refusal instead turned on how light would actually reach rooms in the centre of a building almost 18 metres wide.
Why the Class Q appeal passed the initial tests
Part 3, Class Q of the General Permitted Development Order allows qualifying agricultural buildings to change to residential use, subject to strict limitations and prior approval of specified matters. In this case, the Inspector examined the building’s history because Ashley Parish Council had questioned its occasional use as an events venue before a fire in July 2020. The appellant’s evidence indicated a 7.5-acre agricultural unit and the building’s primary use as a grain store.
The Council had previously accepted that the building met the relevant Class Q limitations. The Inspector also considered a suitability report, which described the main structure as intact and capable of conversion without substantial reconstruction. The earlier events use did not, on the evidence before her, defeat Class Q eligibility. That conclusion was specific to this barn and does not settle the position for other mixed-use agricultural buildings.
The Council refused prior approval under paragraph Q.2(1)(f), design and external appearance, and Q.2(1)(g), adequate natural light in habitable rooms. That distinction is important. This was not a full planning application where every wider countryside objection could be reconsidered from first principles. Our Class Q barn conversion guide explains the limits and prior approval procedure.
Exterior design did not cause the refusal
The barn was approximately 48 metres long and 17.8 metres wide, with a shallow pitched roof, eaves around 4.9 metres high and a ridge rising to seven metres. Its substantial steel frame and corrugated cladding were to be retained. New windows and doors would largely be set into the lower part of the elevations, with narrow upper openings and flush rooflights.
The Council was concerned that the windows and doors would give the barn an unduly domestic appearance in its open countryside setting. The Inspector disagreed. Class Q is not confined to picturesque old barns: modern steel portal-frame agricultural buildings can qualify too, and some new fenestration is normally necessary to make a conversion work.
The Inspector considered that the building would retain its agricultural character from the surrounding roads and countryside. In that respect the Class Q appeal succeeded. This is a useful reminder that the design test concerns the actual appearance and effect of the proposed works, rather than an expectation that a converted barn should remain visually unchanged.
Class Q appeal turns on daylight inside the building
The six proposed four-bedroom homes were arranged back-to-back across the width of the structure. The outer living spaces and some bedrooms would receive light through conventional wall windows or glazed doors. Twenty other bedrooms, however, were in the deeper central portion of the barn, with no external walls and no vertical windows.
High-level roof openings were indicated on the plans, near the ridge and about 6.5 to seven metres above the ground-floor rooms. But the drawings did not show clearly whether they represented external roof apertures or internal ceiling openings. There were no cross-sections establishing the internal heights and route that daylight would take into the bedrooms.
The Class Q appeal failed because the Inspector lacked the technical information needed to establish adequate natural light. She noted the possibility of deep enclosed shafts, uncertain glazing characteristics, structural obstructions and the north-facing orientation of some openings. Without room sections or daylight calculations, it was not possible to establish that the bedrooms would receive enough usable light.
Why Building Regulations evidence was not enough
The appellant referred to Building Regulations and a window-area ratio of one-fifteenth of floor area. The Inspector did not accept that this resolved the prior approval test. Building Regulations address a separate statutory regime, while the relationship between a high-level rooflight and the light reaching an occupied room depends on its position, opening size, shaft arrangement and surrounding construction.
The Inspector found that there was a high likelihood of seriously reduced daylight in the internal rooms, particularly during overcast winter months. Her conclusion was that “adequate natural light would not be provided in all habitable rooms”. Under paragraph W.2A of the permitted development procedure, prior approval had to be refused once that deficiency was identified.
There is a practical point here for the Class Q appeal and future conversion schemes. A rooflight symbol on a floor plan does not establish the quality of daylight at the room below. Designers should show sections through difficult rooms and provide clear, proportionate lighting evidence where an unusually deep plan or tall building makes ordinary assumptions unreliable.
Other objections and the planning lesson
The Inspector did not consider that the established vehicle access, parking and turning arrangements created unacceptable transport effects. Nor was an alleged lack of sustainable transport a separate ground for defeating this proposal under Class Q. Several local objections concerned matters such as utility capacity, protected species and trees, which were not all matters capable of being reopened under the particular prior approval provisions.
The finding on daylight should not be mistaken for a general refusal of agricultural conversion in North Northamptonshire. A different internal layout, better room positioning, clearer rooflight details or robust technical calculations might produce a different assessment. Nothing in the appeal establishes that every deep-plan barn must fail, or that rooflights can never provide adequate natural light.
For applicants, the strongest lesson from this Class Q appeal is to identify the least convincing rooms before submission, not after refusal. Eligibility and attractive exterior drawings are only part of the case. Where bedrooms are buried within a large agricultural building, the evidence must demonstrate that the homes will function properly inside as well as look acceptable outside. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase.

0 Comments