A four-home Devon barn scheme survived a late refusal, but the owner still had to prove the works qualified as conversion.
Class Q can make a barn conversion possible, but the building, the proposed works and the land around it all need careful consideration. Here we collect changes to the English permitted development right and decisions illustrating its limits. The reports explain the practical lessons, while the main Class Q guide sets out the current requirements.For the background and current guidance, see our Class Q guide and agriculture and equestrian planning.
A four-home Devon barn scheme survived a late refusal, but the owner still had to prove the works qualified as conversion.
A Class Q appeal at Malvern Hills passed the barn conversion test but failed because the agricultural evidence did not prove eligibility.
An Inspector rejected the council’s assumption that two neighbouring barns would be demolished, then accepted the main barn’s conversion and existing access.
The applicant defeated the council’s restriction argument, but missing elevations and sections left the Inspector unable to establish a lawful barn conversion.
The same Inspector decided two Class Q appeals on the same day, allowing one barn conversion and dismissing the other over farm impacts.
Seven Class Q homes failed on noise evidence even though the Inspector accepted the proposed demolition was necessary and the barns remained conversions.
The farm access measured about 4.8m against Somerset’s 5m standard, but the Inspector found it could operate safely for six homes.
Two Class Q appeals show why substantial works can remain a conversion, while retaining parts of a steel frame is not enough. Broom Farm succeeded; Washdyke Farm failed.
A Hampshire Class Q appeal failed even though the Inspector accepted that the building had genuinely been used for agriculture. The missing evidence concerned the separate question of the established agricultural unit.
A Worcestershire Class Q appeal has confirmed that prior approval is limited to the matters in the GPDO and cannot become a general residential amenity assessment.
A Somerset appeal has confirmed that a Class Q barn conversion does not automatically turn the wider former farmyard into residential land.
Changes to Class Q. It has been refreshed to allow up to 10 dwellings. The limit has been raised to 1,000 sq m and extensions are now allowed!
Big changes are planned for permitted development rights affecting Class MA, Class G, Barns, shops, offices and much more. Read on for the info!
Journalist, broadcaster or producer? Need a quick comment on a planning story, policy change or decision?
Planning Geek can help you understand the options for your property or development.