Skip to content
Planning Geek logo

Planning consultancyBacked by the UK's leading planning resource

PLANNING NEWS

Liverpool HMO appeal: full costs award

An Inspector allows two Liverpool HMOs and awards full appeal costs after finding the council's noise objections inadequately supported.

by | 20th November 2026 07:54 | AppealsChange of UseHMO

A Liverpool HMO appeal has been allowed and a full award of appeal costs made against Liverpool City Council after an Inspector rejected its concerns about noise from two proposed houses in multiple occupation. Both decisions were issued on 19 November 2026 and concern upper floors of premises on Smithdown Road.

Inspector C Evans granted planning permission for two Use Class C4 HMOs on Smithdown Road, above existing commercial units. The Inspector also found that the council had failed to substantiate its refusal with evidence specific to the site and had caused the appellant unnecessary expense. The appeal reference is 6013920.

This Liverpool HMO appeal matters beyond the individual building because it tests how councils use concentration data, assumptions about tenants and emerging planning policies when refusing HMO schemes. It does not mean that HMO concentrations or noise can never justify refusal. It shows the importance of explaining the actual likely harm, supported by relevant evidence.

Why the Liverpool HMO appeal was allowed

The application sought to change the first and second floors into two HMOs for between three and six people, with alterations to windows, cycle and bin storage and removal of an outbuilding. The ground-floor shops would remain. The council argued that additional residents, visitors and late-night movements would cause noise and disturbance to neighbours.

The Inspector’s assessment was rooted in the surroundings. Smithdown Road is a busy commercial street with buses, shops and other premises in use into the evening. Having seen that environment during the site visit, the Inspector was not persuaded that movements associated with the proposed HMOs would be noticeably greater than existing activity. The decision also recorded the absence of objections from the council’s environmental health team.

The Liverpool HMO appeal is not a blanket finding that up to 10 occupants have no amenity impact. The Inspector took account of the detailed access arrangements, adjoining uses, existing street activity and proposed acoustic insulation. It was a judgement about this location, not a finding that the same intensity of occupation would be acceptable on every residential street.

On parking, the highway authority had not objected. The council’s own assessment suggested relatively low vehicle ownership by future occupiers, and nearby public transport was readily available. The Inspector concluded that the likely additional parking activity would not materially change noise conditions.

HMO concentrations and emerging Liverpool policy

The council referred to evidence prepared for its emerging Local Plan suggesting that more than a quarter of residential properties in the area were HMOs. However, the Inspector regarded that material as generalised rather than evidence of harm from the particular proposal. There were no recorded noise complaints or police reports before the Inspector for the period when the property had reportedly operated as a larger unauthorised HMO.

The proposed new HMO policy H8 had not yet been adopted. The Inspector noted that the Regulation 19 consultation had closed on 30 September 2026, that objections had been received and that the plan remained at an early stage. The draft policy therefore attracted limited weight. That was an assessment of the emerging policy’s status on the decision date, not a conclusion that Liverpool could never adopt stronger HMO controls.

The Liverpool HMO appeal should also be distinguished from the separate question of whether a proposal requires planning permission. Our HMO planning guide explains the relationship between Use Class C4, larger sui generis HMOs and Article 4 directions. An Article 4 direction can remove a permitted development route, but it does not automatically require every application to be refused.

The appellant pointed to an existing permission for two ordinary C3 dwellings as a possible fallback. Crucially, the Inspector did not need to rely on that fallback: the proposed HMOs were judged acceptable on their own planning merits. It would therefore be misleading to present this as an appeal won by demonstrating the greater harm of a C3 alternative.

Full costs award for unsupported refusal

The separate costs decision is the sharpest part of the case. In the Liverpool HMO appeal costs ruling, the Inspector said the council had relied on “vague and generalised assertions” rather than robust evidence of why the proposal would materially worsen noise and disturbance in an already active local centre. Local objections had been considered, but they did not remove the council’s responsibility to put forward sound planning reasons.

The Inspector found unreasonable behaviour causing unnecessary or wasted appeal expense and ordered Liverpool City Council to pay the appellant’s costs of the proceedings. The amount was not fixed in the decision. It is to be agreed or assessed, so this is a full costs award, not an announcement of a particular sum of public money.

There is an important distinction between losing a planning appeal and being ordered to pay costs. A decision-maker can make a defensible judgement that an Inspector disagrees with. Here, the additional finding was that the council had not substantiated the case it advanced. Planning Geek’s guide to costs awards in planning appeals explains the test for unreasonable behaviour and wasted expense.

For applicants, the practical lesson is to answer a refusal reason with evidence about the actual use and surroundings, not merely to assert that national policy supports HMOs. For councils, the lesson is to distinguish concentration statistics and general perceptions from a defensible, site-specific assessment of harm.

What the planning permission actually requires

The permission contains safeguards rather than leaving management to goodwill. Among the conditions are removal of the existing unauthorised rear outbuilding before occupation, provision and retention of ten cycle-parking spaces, and implementation of specified noise mitigation, ventilation and acoustic insulation measures.

A management plan must also be approved before occupation. It is required to deal with waste, tenant obligations and a 24-hour contact for neighbours. The appellant provided a unilateral undertaking securing a payment towards off-site tree planting, which the Inspector accepted as satisfying the relevant local plan requirement.

The Liverpool HMO appeal therefore illustrates a familiar but important distinction: a scheme can be acceptable subject to enforceable mitigation without the absence of harm being assumed. The conditions, approved plans and management measures define what has actually been allowed.

The Planning Inspectorate’s appeal record gives the official decision. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase. The separate costs decision is dated 19 November 2026.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Affected by this story, or spotted something we should check? Report an issue with this article

Planning news by email

Get the latest Planning Geek stories in one daily digest.

Finding Planning Geek useful?
Buy Ian a coffee to say thanks

Media enquiries

Journalist, broadcaster or producer? Need a quick comment on a planning story, policy change or decision?

Request a comment →

YouTube

Planning Geek on YouTube

Watch Ian explain permitted development, use classes, planning applications and current planning changes.

Watch on YouTube

Latest planning news

Rural leisure appeal fails on highways

Rural leisure appeal fails on highways

Three farm barns proposed for sports and recreation fail at appeal over rural road safety and missing biodiversity information, despite acceptable Green Belt impacts.