A grey belt appeal at Lambley in Nottinghamshire has secured permission in principle for up to six homes on a caravan-storage yard. Inspector Richard Gilbert allowed appeal 6013423 on 19 November 2026 after deciding that the site was sustainably located under the revised National Planning Policy Framework, despite a very low national connectivity score.
The decision overturns Gedling Borough Council’s refusal of application 2026/0222 at Lambley Caravan Storage off Spring Lane. The council accepted that the land qualified as grey belt and that its development would not fundamentally undermine the Green Belt’s purposes. The dispute instead concerned whether residents could make realistic journeys without relying on private cars.
What makes the grey belt appeal noteworthy is the Inspector’s use of the government’s Connectivity Tool. A score of 42 looked poor when judged across the country but placed the site in the top fifth of locations within comparable rural categories. That distinction helped the Inspector conclude that the proposed housing satisfied the transport-related requirements of national Green Belt policy.
Why the grey belt appeal meets national policy
The appeal site consists of hardstanding used to store caravans. It sits at the end of a private access road, with fields, hedges and trees on some boundaries and existing development nearby. The proposal was for a range of one to six dwellings rather than a final layout or a fixed design for six houses.
The August 2026 Framework’s Policy GB7(1)(g) provides a route for housing on grey belt land where the remaining Green Belt purposes are not fundamentally undermined, there is a demonstrable unmet need and the location is sustainable. Gedling did not dispute the first two Green Belt elements. The council also lacked a five year housing land supply, demonstrating unmet housing need in the terms considered by the Inspector.
That left sustainable transport as the central obstacle. The grey belt appeal was not allowed just because the yard was hardstanding or because homes were needed. The Inspector assessed the walking routes, bus service and connectivity evidence in considerable detail before concluding that the proposal was not inappropriate Green Belt development. Our guide to grey belt and Green Belt explains why those tests are separate.
A connectivity score of 42 was not the whole answer
Policy TR3 of the revised Framework calls for the Connectivity Tool to be considered alongside other quantitative and qualitative evidence. The Inspector recorded that the site’s score was 42, classified as very low nationally. Taken in isolation, that could have appeared to undermine the proposal’s suitability.
However, the tool’s guidance requires scores to be interpreted against relevant comparators. The Inspector considered the site to fall within either the rural village or rural hamlets and isolated dwellings classification. Against either of those categories, 42 placed it in the top 20 per cent nationally. He called this “a contextually high score” and agreed that the location met Policy TR3.
This is the important distinction in the grey belt appeal. National percentile rankings are not automatically a yes-or-no verdict on a rural site. The relevant classification, the quality of practical journeys and the alternatives to private-car use all matter. A different rural score or bus service could lead to a different conclusion.
Why the bus route made a difference
The private access road was predominantly straight, level and recently surfaced, although it lacked footways and street lighting. The Inspector found that its light traffic and physical character did not make walking to the nearest bus stops unduly discouraging. Those stops were approximately 400 to 500 metres away, slightly beyond the preferred figure in some local guidance.
From the site, residents could reach footways on Spring Lane and a crossing point towards the westbound stop. The Inspector took account of sightlines, road conditions, provision for wheelchairs and mobility scooters, and the absence of identified highway safety problems at that crossing. He did not treat the existence of a 40 mph road as proof that the walking route was unacceptable.
The number 61 bus was recorded as operating every half hour on six days of the week, reducing to hourly on Sundays, connecting Lambley, Calverton and Nottingham. This gave potential residents a credible alternative to driving. In another decision mentioned by the council, appeal 6001523 near Ravenshead, the bus service and walking arrangements were materially less convenient. The grey belt appeal therefore turned on specific evidence rather than a generic assertion that village-edge homes are unsustainable.
What permission in principle actually grants
Permission in principle, commonly called PiP, has two stages. The first determines whether the proposed location, land use and amount of housing are acceptable. The later technical details consent stage addresses matters such as layout, design, access construction, drainage, ecology and other detailed requirements. The Lambley decision grants the first stage only.
Interested parties raised concerns about drainage, utilities, land ownership, access width and the site’s surrounding character. Some of those points were either private legal matters outside the planning decision or details for a later application. The Inspector also rejected the suggestion that the proposal would cause the merger of Lambley with Nottingham in the circumstances established by the evidence.
A request from Severn Trent Water for conditions could not be dealt with by imposing conditions on this PiP decision. Detailed matters, including biodiversity net gain and air quality, would be addressed through technical details consent where applicable. Our permission in principle guide explains that distinction and why an applicant must not treat first-stage approval as authority to begin building.
Practical lessons for other small grey belt sites
The Inspector gave substantial weight to the contribution of new homes towards meeting local housing need. He also found that the proposal would comply with the relevant development plan policies and the Framework’s Green Belt and transport provisions. No very special circumstances case was needed once the development was found not to be inappropriate.
For developers, the grey belt appeal shows the value of obtaining and interpreting the Connectivity Tool results properly. A low national score may need to be compared with similar rural places, then supported by evidence about actual walking routes, crossing points, bus frequency, travel distances and accessible transport options. Neither a favourable rural percentile nor an accepted grey belt designation alone secures consent.
The decision of 19 November 2026 is appeal 6013423. The Planning Inspectorate appeal record provides the official reference. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase. The result is permission in principle for one to six homes, with technical details consent still needed before development can proceed.

0 Comments