A Bacup enforcement appeal has been dismissed even though an Inspector found errors in the council’s notice requiring the removal of shopfront shutters and an illuminated LED sign. Inspector R Hitchcock issued the decision on 16 November 2026, correcting the notice and its plan but leaving the requirement to remove the unauthorised work in force.
The case concerns a retail unit in Burnley Road, Bacup, where Rossendale Borough Council served an enforcement notice on 14 October 2025. The notice referred to photographs that had not been enclosed and used a plan extending beyond the relevant shop unit. Neither defect was sufficiently serious to invalidate the notice once the Inspector made corrections.
The Bacup enforcement appeal shows why technical errors in an enforcement notice do not automatically make it unenforceable. It also highlights the limits of an appeal brought under section 174(2)(f): arguments about shop security, streetscape harm or the merits of illuminated signage could not resolve a challenge confined to the steps required to remedy the breach.
Bacup enforcement appeal concerns shutters and a sign
The notice alleged that external metal roller shutters, a shutter box and a large illuminated LED sign had been installed on the front of the building without planning permission. It required their permanent removal, together with repair of damage to the stonework caused by installing or removing them. The stated compliance period was six months.
The appellant, Mohammed Qadeer, challenged the notice on ground (f) of section 174(2) of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990. This ground concerns whether the steps required by a notice exceed what is necessary to remedy the breach of planning control or the injury to amenity caused by it. It is different from ground (a), which allows consideration of granting planning permission for the alleged development.
For businesses contemplating an illuminated sign or a substantial change to a fascia, the Planning Geek guide to advertisement consent explains the separate advertisement-control considerations. That guidance does not remove the need to establish whether physical shopfront works require planning permission in their own right.
Why the missing photographs did not invalidate the notice
The Bacup enforcement appeal exposed a clear drafting problem. The notice required removal of the works by reference to photographs described as enclosed with the document. However, the copies before the Inspector contained no such photographs. The Inspector expressly identified this as “a clear omission from the Notice”.
There was also an issue with the plan. Although the notice identified the premises in Burnley Road, its plan apparently showed the combined footprint of two neighbouring buildings. The retail unit with the shutters and LED sign occupied one part of that space, while a separate entrance serving upper floors was not part of the shop.
Inspector Hitchcock considered that the plan could be corrected to cover the relevant retail premises alone. The change would narrow the notice’s site area but would not exclude the works actually alleged to be unauthorised. Likewise, deleting the reference to missing photographs would still leave a sufficiently clear description of what had to be removed.
The Inspector therefore used the power under section 176(1)(a) of the 1990 Act to correct the notice, replacing the plan and removing the words referring to photographs. The Inspector found that neither correction would cause injustice to the appellant or the council. The errors were real, but not fatal.
The courts’ approach to enforcement notice defects
The Bacup enforcement appeal applied established court authority on what an enforcement notice must communicate. In Miller-Mead v Minister of Housing and Local Government, reported at [1963] 2 QB 196 and [1963] 2 WLR 225, the central requirement is that a recipient should understand what is alleged and, with reasonable certainty, what must be done to remedy it.
The Inspector also cited Oates v Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government and Canterbury City Council [2018] EWCA Civ 2229. That Court of Appeal authority addresses how an enforcement notice is interpreted and when defects affect its validity. The approach is not to treat every imprecision as automatically nullifying the notice.
Applying those principles, the Inspector considered the notice as a whole. Its description of the shutter, shutter box and LED sign identified the works clearly enough. The Council’s shopfront guidance further helped explain the relevant part of the premises and the concern being addressed.
The legal lesson is not that councils may issue hopelessly vague notices and expect inspectors to rewrite them. The key is whether a particular mistake can be corrected without injustice and whether the remaining notice still tells the recipient what breach is alleged and what steps are required.
Why ground (f) did not save the shutters
The Bacup enforcement appeal ultimately failed because the steps required were directed at removing the works alleged to be unauthorised. The notice did not merely complain about the shutters’ appearance and seek some improvement to their design. It alleged the installation of those works without the necessary permission and required their removal to remedy that breach.
The appellant argued that the shutters were needed for security and suggested that they caused little harm compared with other nearby shopfronts. There were also proposals to reduce the LED sign’s illumination or replace it. Those submissions raised questions about the acceptability of alternative designs, but the appeal had not been brought on ground (a).
Inspector Hitchcock explained that, because no appeal had been made on ground (a), the planning merits were not before the Inspector, so there was no scope to assess whether the removal requirements were excessive in relation to any injury to amenity. The only question was whether lesser steps would remedy the breach identified in the notice. No sufficiently detailed alternative was demonstrated that would do so.
Changing the brightness of a sign, for example, would not necessarily remedy the unauthorised installation of the sign itself. Nor would a shutter’s claimed security benefits alter the legal question on ground (f). Consequently, the Inspector dismissed that ground and upheld the corrected notice.
What the decision means for shop owners and councils
The decision leaves the removal requirements in force, subject to the Inspector’s corrections and the applicable notice timetable. It does not grant planning permission for the shutter box, shutters or LED sign. Equally, it does not determine the planning merits of a different design that might later be submitted for the Council’s consideration.
For shop owners, the Bacup enforcement appeal illustrates the importance of choosing the correct appeal grounds. If the case is that the development should receive planning permission, a challenge confined to ground (f) will not ordinarily provide an opportunity to argue that point. It addresses the adequacy of the remedy, not the full planning balance.
For planning authorities, the case is a reminder to check site plans and attachments before serving notices. Accurate documents reduce the scope for uncertainty and legal dispute, even where an Inspector might later correct a limited defect. Clear identification of both the breach and the required steps remains essential.
The full decision, appeal APP/B2355/C/25/3375745, was issued on 16 November 2026 and is also available on AppealBase. The notice was corrected and upheld, rather than quashed.

0 Comments