Skip to content
Planning Geek logo

Planning consultancyBacked by the UK's leading planning resource

PLANNING NEWS

Dacorum storage appeal fails despite grey belt status

Three modular storage units in Dacorum's Green Belt failed despite an agreed grey belt status, with agricultural need and sustainable access unproven.

A Dacorum storage appeal concerning three modular units on Green Belt land near Hemel Hempstead has been dismissed, despite the site being accepted as grey belt. Inspector P Terceiro rejected the retrospective scheme on 16 November 2026 after finding that the buildings were not shown to be needed for agriculture, that an unmet storage need was unproven and that the rural location failed the sustainable-transport test.

The application concerned three dark-green modular storage units arranged around a gravel courtyard at Plot 4, Cupid Green Lane. The proposal also included raised planting beds, hardstanding, landscaping, solar panels and other infrastructure described as supporting rural land management. Dacorum Borough Council had refused application 26/01143/RET, and the appellant sought permission to retain the development.

The Dacorum storage appeal provides a useful warning for landowners who assume that a little horticulture or a grey belt designation is enough to justify storage buildings in the countryside. The Inspector separated the claimed agricultural purpose, the grey belt policy criteria, landscape impacts and the overall Green Belt balance, with each requiring its own evidence.

Why the Dacorum storage appeal concerned agriculture

The development was described as a low-intensity rural storage and land-management compound with machinery, equipment and tools, alongside raised growing beds and planting. The Inspector considered whether it qualified for the agricultural, horticultural or forestry exception to the national Green Belt restrictions.

Section 336 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 gives agriculture a broad definition that includes horticulture and several forms of farming. But simply saying that storage supports land management does not establish that the units are genuinely required for an agricultural activity.

During the site visit, the Inspector saw building materials, domestic belongings, bricks, scaffolding and stepladders. The limited information about cultivation and land management did not explain why three large storage units were required for the small raised beds. In the decision, the Inspector wrote: “Overall, I saw very little to suggest that this is a place of agriculture.”

The Inspector was therefore not satisfied that the development was needed for agriculture and concluded that it failed Policy GB7(a) of the August 2026 National Planning Policy Framework. Our guide to agricultural and equestrian land uses explains why the actual activity and evidence matter, rather than a label given to a proposal.

Grey belt agreement was not enough

The Dacorum storage appeal also tested the relatively new grey belt policy exception. The parties agreed that the land met the grey belt definition and the Inspector found no persuasive evidence that the development would fundamentally undermine the purposes of the remaining Green Belt across the wider plan area.

That agreement met only one part of Policy GB7(g). The Inspector also had to consider whether there was an evidenced unmet need for the type of development proposed and whether the location supported sustainable patterns of movement. The applicant said the units stored landscaping equipment, tools and machinery, but supplied no compelling evidence of an unmet need for this storage use.

Public transport was some distance away and, on the evidence, was not a realistic alternative for visitors. The nearby footpaths were also unlikely to support routine access other than recreational journeys. People using the development would therefore largely rely on private vehicles, contrary to the sustainable-location criterion.

Because those tests had not been met, the scheme did not qualify for the grey belt policy exception. This is an important distinction: the fact that a site is classified as grey belt does not mean that every proposal on it is appropriate development. For background see Planning Geek’s explanation of grey belt and Green Belt.

Three storage units harmed Green Belt openness

The Inspector found that the land had previously been an undeveloped part of an agricultural field and that no contrary evidence had been produced. Placing three buildings on that land introduced physical mass and built form where there had previously been none.

Even though the modular units were only single storey, the cumulative volume and their arrangement around a courtyard reduced both the spatial and visual openness of the Green Belt. They also represented encroachment into the countryside, one of the matters national Green Belt policy seeks to prevent.

The Dacorum storage appeal therefore failed the Green Belt test in two separate ways. It was inappropriate development because it did not meet an exception, and it produced additional harm to openness and countryside character. The Inspector assessed that extra harm as moderate in extent but still gave substantial weight to Green Belt harm overall.

The surrounding area had already been divided into plots containing sheds, shipping containers, fences and other structures. Rather than treating that as a reason to accept yet more buildings, the Inspector considered that the three new units added to a fragmented, cluttered appearance. Their dark-green profiled steel and associated stored items did not blend sufficiently into the rural setting.

The Chilterns National Landscape point was different

The site lies outside the Chilterns National Landscape, which is designated on land beyond Cupid Green Lane, some distance from the plot. Although the Inspector had regard to the duty to seek to further the conservation and enhancement of its natural beauty, the decision found that the visual effects of the storage development would be largely confined to its immediate surroundings.

On that particular issue, the Inspector concluded that the development conserved the landscape and scenic beauty of the Chilterns National Landscape. The wider area’s local character, however, was still harmed by the structures and the storage of miscellaneous items. These are different findings, and the absence of National Landscape harm did not resolve the more local concerns.

The Council had also referred to the Hertfordshire Local Nature Recovery Strategy and its green infrastructure policies. But it did not provide robust evidence explaining how the relevant mapped or unmapped nature-recovery actions applied to the site. The Inspector therefore did not find that a conflict with the local green infrastructure policy had been adequately demonstrated.

These findings underline the importance of identifying the specific policy harm supported by the evidence. A scheme can be dismissed even where some of the Council’s objections are not sustained. Further guidance on this wider issue is available in our green infrastructure planning guide.

Why very special circumstances were not established

The applicant relied partly on solar power, battery storage, rainwater harvesting and planting to demonstrate environmental benefits. The Inspector gave those measures moderate positive weight, recognising that the site could operate substantially independently of mains electricity and offer some ecological opportunities.

The Inspector attached negligible weight to claims that the development would support business growth, because there was little information about the business itself or the employment or operational need being served. The proposed planting did not remove the visual harm caused by the buildings, and the possibility of controlling outdoor storage through a condition did not adequately address that harm.

The Dacorum storage appeal was ultimately dismissed because those benefits did not clearly outweigh the substantial weight required to be given to inappropriate development in the Green Belt, together with the loss of openness and local landscape harm. The Inspector found that the very special circumstances necessary to justify permission did not exist.

The decision is a reminder that off-grid technology and landscaping can strengthen a planning case without proving that the underlying buildings are necessary or appropriately located. Evidence of agricultural purpose and storage demand must come first when those matters are relied upon to secure a policy exception.

What landowners can learn from the refusal

The Dacorum storage appeal is especially relevant to small rural plots where owners install modular units, add a little planting or horticultural activity, and subsequently seek permission to retain everything. An Inspector will look beyond the description on the application form to the actual uses, the items stored, the supporting evidence and the effect of the buildings in their setting.

Here, the Inspector inspected the completed units but determined the appeal on the submitted plans and supporting information. Their physical presence did not change the need to justify the scheme under the relevant Green Belt and agricultural policies. Equally, accepting grey belt status did not remove the need to prove unmet need and sustainable location.

The appeal was brought by Sorin Boicu against Dacorum Borough Council’s refusal of retrospective application 26/01143/RET. Inspector P Terceiro dismissed appeal 6013399 on 16 November 2026. The full decision is also available on AppealBase.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Affected by this story, or spotted something we should check? Report an issue with this article

Planning news by email

Get the latest Planning Geek stories in one daily digest.

Finding Planning Geek useful?
Buy Ian a coffee to say thanks

Media enquiries

Journalist, broadcaster or producer? Need a quick comment on a planning story, policy change or decision?

Request a comment →

YouTube

Planning Geek on YouTube

Watch Ian explain permitted development, use classes, planning applications and current planning changes.

Watch on YouTube

Latest planning news