A barn conversion appeal at Merkin Farm in Wiltshire has succeeded despite the Inspector accepting that future residents would rely heavily on cars. The existing steel-framed agricultural building could qualify for reuse within the Green Belt, while the benefits of one additional home outweighed limited concerns about access to services.
Inspector E Pickernell allowed appeal 6010547 on 18 November 2026, overturning Wiltshire Council’s refusal of planning application PL/2025/04403 at Doctors Hill, Ashley, near Box. The proposal retains the building’s main structural frame and concrete slab, removes several lean-to additions and converts the remaining building into a separate dwelling.
The barn conversion appeal also tests how the August 2026 National Planning Policy Framework interacts with older rural conversion policies, the Cotswold National Landscape and protected bat habitat. It is not a general consent for new homes in the Green Belt, or a decision under Class Q permitted development rights.
Why the barn conversion appeal met the Green Belt reuse exception
The central question was whether the work amounted to the reuse of a permanent and substantial building, rather than effectively erecting a new one. Policy GB7 of the August 2026 Framework allows specified reuse of existing buildings in the Green Belt where the relevant tests are met. The agricultural structure had a steel frame, concrete slab, corrugated roof, blockwork and timber boarding.
A structural report dated 1 November 2024 assessed the retained frame and slab as being in good condition. Inspector Pickernell’s site visit was consistent with that evidence. Although several lean-to structures would be demolished, the main part of the barn would remain in place and its overall rural appearance would be retained after insulation, cladding and modest new windows were added.
The Inspector concluded that the scheme would not comprise inappropriate development in the Green Belt
. That distinction is important for this barn conversion appeal: there was no need to demonstrate very special circumstances, but the remaining planning consequences still had to be assessed.
Rural location and conflicts with Wiltshire policy
Merkin Farm lies in open countryside outside defined settlement limits, close to Ashley. The village has limited services, and Box offers more facilities but is beyond a comfortable walk for most residents. A bus stop on Bath Road was said to be 9 to 13 minutes away on foot, although the route included steep sections without lighting or pavements.
The Inspector expected a high level of dependence on private cars. This was a genuine conflict with the accessibility requirements of Core Policy 48 of the Wiltshire Core Strategy, not something made acceptable simply because the building already stood on the land.
Core Policy 48 also favoured employment, tourism, cultural and community reuse ahead of housing. The narrow access made some of those alternatives impractical, but the Inspector was not convinced that tourism accommodation was necessarily unworkable. There remained a degree of conflict with the local policy’s preferred sequence of uses.
However, the restriction on residential reuse in that older local policy was materially inconsistent with the newer national Green Belt reuse provisions. The Inspector applied Annex A of the Framework and gave that inconsistent part of the local policy very little weight. For the distinction between a countryside policy restraint and a national route to approval, see our guide to building outside settlement boundaries.
National Landscape and bat protection were examined separately
The site is within the Cotswold National Landscape, on a small plateau surrounded by mature vegetation. The agricultural building is set below the nearby road and is not prominent from public viewpoints. Removing lean-tos would reduce built form, while additional windows and a domestic garden would introduce some residential character.
After considering the statutory duty under section 85 of the Countryside and Rights of Way Act 2000, the Inspector found the effects on landscape character to be neutral. The surrounding hedgerows and the retention of a recognisably rural building were important to that assessment, not an assumption that all barn conversions are visually harmless.
The barn conversion appeal also involved the Bath and Bradford on Avon Bats Special Area of Conservation. Although the building had negligible bat roost potential, nearby hedges, scrub and woodland could support commuting and foraging by qualifying bat species. Extra lighting and household activity therefore required assessment.
Natural England accepted mitigation including bat boxes, retained boundary habitat and a lighting scheme keeping illumination at hedgerows below 0.2 lux. After an appropriate assessment, the Inspector concluded that the scheme would not harm the integrity of the protected site, subject to enforceable safeguards. Our guide to protected species in planning explains why lighting, not just physical roost disturbance, can matter.
A 2.8-year housing supply shifted the balance
Wiltshire Council could demonstrate only 2.8 years of deliverable housing sites on the evidence before the Inspector. The additional dwelling would be a modest numerical contribution, but the August Framework’s Policy HO7 led the Inspector to give the housing benefit substantial weight. Policy L2 added support for using a vacant or underused building more efficiently.
Biodiversity net gain attracted moderate positive weight. Against those benefits, the limited harm arising from car dependence was not enough to justify refusal. The National Landscape and protected site findings were neutral rather than positive benefits, and the Inspector carefully distinguished those categories in the planning balance.
The barn conversion appeal ultimately succeeded because the national policy benefits were not substantially outweighed by the identified harm. That is different from saying that car-dependent development is always acceptable. The extent of local services, the characteristics of the reused building and the particular housing supply position all influenced the result.
For the housing evidence background, see our five-year housing land supply guide. A single converted dwelling may attract considerable policy weight where supply is significantly deficient, but the weight must still be judged on the individual decision’s facts.
Conditions and what applicants should learn
Permission is subject to approved drawings and a normal commencement condition. Before external lighting is installed, its height, design, location and intensity must be approved. The consent also requires two off-road parking spaces, ecological mitigation before occupation and landscaping safeguards for vegetation relevant to bats.
The Inspector did not impose a separate biodiversity net gain condition because the statutory biodiversity gain plan requirement already operated. Nor was a blanket removal of future householder permitted development rights accepted without clear justification. These are useful reminders to distinguish necessary conditions from requirements already imposed by legislation.
The nearby Stables appeal, reference 6009637, was expressly considered but not treated as decisive. That earlier scheme involved part of a stable building already used as accommodation and a rural worker occupation restriction. Our report on the earlier Stables appeal shows both the similarities in Green Belt reasoning and the difference in the permission granted.
A practical application should therefore contain credible evidence of the existing structure, the precise amount of demolition, the legal basis for reuse, walking and transport conditions, visual effects, protected species and a workable mitigation strategy. The barn conversion appeal does not replace those assessments with a blanket Green Belt exemption.
The decision is Planning Inspectorate appeal 6010547, dated 18 November 2026. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase. The brief Inspector quotation above is Planning Inspectorate material acknowledged under the Open Government Licence.

0 Comments