A horse walker appeal in the Redditch Green Belt has been allowed after an Inspector found that a substantial equestrian exercise structure could qualify as an appropriate outdoor recreation facility. The crucial distinction was its position beside an established group of buildings, where both the spatial and visual impact on openness would be limited.
Inspector K Townend allowed the appeal on 18 November 2026 at Old Yarr, Blaze Lane, Astwood Bank, Worcestershire. Redditch Borough Council had refused permission for the horse walker, but the Inspector applied the revised August 2026 National Planning Policy Framework and concluded that the proposal was not inappropriate Green Belt development.
The horse walker appeal is particularly useful because an earlier enforcement appeal had concerned the same type of structure. That earlier decision did not settle the revised proposal. The Inspector found that the new position, alongside existing equestrian buildings and hardstanding, materially changed how the development would be perceived in the countryside.
Why the horse walker appeal was allowed
The proposed installation would sit on existing hardstanding next to a complex of four houses, equestrian buildings and paddocks. The land lies north of Blaze Lane, a narrow rural road south-west of Redditch, in countryside dominated by farmland and scattered residential properties. The question was whether the structure would constitute inappropriate development and, if it did, whether very special circumstances would justify it.
The Inspector considered Redditch Local Plan Policy 8, which refers Green Belt exceptions to national policy. Under Policy GB6 of the August 2026 Framework, new development is inappropriate unless it falls within an exception set out in Policy GB7. Those exceptions include appropriate facilities for outdoor sport and outdoor recreation, where their effect on openness is minimised and there is no significant conflict with the Green Belt’s purposes.
The horse walker appeal turned on that outdoor recreation exception, identified as Policy GB7(1)(f)(iv). An exercise walker for horses can be associated with outdoor sport and recreation, so the Inspector assessed the structure’s particular size, position and impact rather than treating every new installation on Green Belt land as unacceptable.
The Inspector also addressed a potentially important misconception. Private rather than public recreation did not disqualify the proposal: there is no requirement in Policy GB7 for such uses to be public
. That does not make private equestrian proposals automatically acceptable. Their actual relationship to existing uses, impact on openness and effect on Green Belt purposes still have to be demonstrated.
Existing hardstanding and a new location mattered
The proposed walker was a relatively large structure with a substantial footprint and volume. The Inspector did not minimise those characteristics, but noted that the chosen position would be close to the existing equestrian complex and would not project further into open countryside than structures already there.
The applicants relied on hardstanding, though its planning status was not conclusively resolved. The Inspector expressly considered the possibility that this was not previously developed land. Even on that assumption, the structure would stand alongside an existing group of buildings and surfaced areas, limiting the additional spatial impact.
In the horse walker appeal, visibility from the highway and surrounding fields was just as important. Tall gates and a field shelter stood between the proposed location and Blaze Lane. The Inspector accepted the findings of a landscape and visual appraisal that assessed four viewpoints and found minor to negligible effects, consistent with observations on the site visit.
This case is a useful reminder that Green Belt openness has visual and spatial elements. The fact that hardstanding already exists does not automatically make a new structure acceptable. Equally, a relatively large object may have a limited additional impact where it is closely grouped with substantial existing development and is not prominent in the landscape.
For the underlying distinctions between Green Belt, grey belt and previously developed land, Planning Geek’s Green Belt and grey belt guide explains why they should not be treated as interchangeable planning concepts.
Why an earlier enforcement appeal did not decide the outcome
The appeal decision refers to an earlier enforcement appeal, APP/Q1825/W/23/3334206, concerning a horse walker. It would be easy to assume that the earlier outcome controlled the new application because the proposed form and scale were similar. The Inspector rejected that shortcut and looked carefully at where this particular proposal would be built.
Although the structure was of the same scale and design as the earlier proposal, the new position was wholly different. It was closely associated with existing buildings and hardstanding, and its relationship with gates, the field shelter and the highway meant it would be perceived as part of the established complex rather than a freestanding incursion into open land.
The horse walker appeal therefore illustrates an important principle of site assessment: different siting can be a material difference even where the physical equipment is similar. The Inspector did not decide that the earlier enforcement position was wrong, nor did the current permission resolve separate outstanding compliance questions.
The Council reported that a horse walker had been placed in an existing manège. The Inspector made clear that this was not the development being considered in the appeal and that any outstanding compliance with the enforcement notice was not determinative of the section 78 application.
No very special circumstances test was needed
Having found only limited effects on the spatial and visual aspects of openness, the Inspector concluded that the proposal minimised harm and would not significantly conflict with the purposes of checking countryside encroachment or unrestricted urban sprawl. The walker was also designed for its equestrian purpose and would fit with the wider group of buildings.
The outcome was that the development fell within Policy GB7(1)(f)(iv) as not inappropriate development. There was no need to move on to the very special circumstances balance, which applies where a proposal is inappropriate in the Green Belt. The Inspector also found no conflict with relevant Redditch Local Plan design policies or the Council’s guidance on equestrian development.
The horse walker appeal is not a general exemption for all horse-related facilities in the Green Belt. An isolated or visually prominent installation, or one that extends a developed area significantly into open fields, may raise materially different issues. Evidence about the precise position, surrounding structures and views remains central.
Planning Geek’s agricultural and equestrian land-use guide also explains why recreational horse keeping and agricultural use cannot simply be treated as identical planning categories.
Conditions and the practical lesson for applicants
Permission was granted subject to two conditions: development must begin within three years and be carried out in accordance with the approved plans. The Inspector did not impose a further drainage condition because the existing hard surface would not materially change runoff.
A suggested condition requiring removal if the structure became unused within ten years was also rejected. The Inspector found that retaining it would not harm Green Belt openness or purposes, whether or not the current residents continued to need it. This was a site-specific assessment, not a conclusion about removal conditions in every case.
For applicants and advisers, the practical priority is a clear location plan and an evidence-based visual assessment that considers the cumulative appearance of the equestrian complex. It is also important to distinguish the proposed development from any previous enforcement notice or appeal, rather than relying on the existence of similar equipment.
The horse walker appeal was decided on 18 November 2026 under reference 6014413. The decision is also available on AppealBase and through the Planning Inspectorate’s appeal service. The applicable national provisions can be read in Policies GB6 and GB7 of the National Planning Policy Framework. The quotation is from Planning Inspectorate material under the Open Government Licence.

0 Comments