Skip to content
Planning Geek logo

Planning consultancyBacked by the UK's leading planning resource

PLANNING NEWS

Rooftop flats appeal fails despite Class A eligibility

Sutton rooftop proposal for 17 flats fails over streetscene harm and overlooking, although the Inspector accepts one disputed block meets Class A.

A rooftop flats appeal in Sutton has been dismissed despite the Inspector accepting that two adjoining address blocks could together qualify as a single purpose-built detached block of flats under permitted development rights. The proposed scheme would have created 17 apartments through additional storeys, but failed because of the appearance of one building and overlooking of neighbouring gardens.

Inspector S F Barnes dismissed appeal 6012081 on 18 November 2026, concerning flats at Jengar Close and Burnell Road in the London Borough of Sutton. The application relied on Schedule 2, Part 20, Class A of the General Permitted Development Order rather than conventional planning permission. A separate dispute about the related bin and cycle stores had also been dismissed in an earlier appeal.

The rooftop flats appeal is important for both developers and councils because an address split does not necessarily decide whether a building is legally one detached block. However, qualifying for a permitted development right is only the first hurdle. The prior approval assessment can still reject a design that harms the appearance of its surroundings or the privacy of existing residents.

Why the rooftop flats appeal was dismissed

The application proposed adding two floors to Blocks A and B, one floor to Block C, two floors to Block D and one floor to Block E. Across the development, the proposed additions would create 17 flats. The buildings occupy a landscaped site enclosed by established residential streets, including Oakhill Road, Lewis Road, Brunswick Road and Burnell Road.

The legal route was Part 20 Class A, which can allow new dwellings immediately above the topmost residential storey of a purpose-built, detached block of flats, subject to limitations and prior approval. The detailed process is explained in Planning Geek’s Part 20 prior approval guide. The Inspector could not simply reconsider the general desirability of additional housing in the town.

The council questioned whether Blocks A and B were two separate buildings and whether those proposed extensions could qualify. Even once that point was resolved in the appellant’s favour, the Inspector identified unacceptable external appearance at Block E and additional overlooking from Blocks A and B. Those were decisive prior approval matters rather than a blanket rejection of rooftop housing.

Two addresses did not necessarily mean two buildings

The Inspector considered the wording of Class A alongside the definition of a block of flats in Part 20 paragraph C. A building can be divided horizontally into self-contained premises even if it also has vertical divisions. Separate entrance arrangements, staircase cores or postal addresses do not automatically create separate buildings for the purposes of the right.

Blocks A and B contained 12 self-contained dwellings and had been constructed at the same time under a historic permission. Their materials, roof profile and elevations read as one external structure, without an obvious physical gap or party wall between them. Historic plans were incomplete, but the evidence indicated that the wider development originally comprised four buildings.

On the balance of probabilities, the Inspector concluded that Blocks A and B form a single building. In the rooftop flats appeal, that finding meant the Class A development description was met for those blocks. It is a useful factual assessment of the building, not a court judgment establishing a universal rule that all attached or similarly designed flats qualify.

The practical point is to assemble the original permission, plans, sections, construction history and physical evidence before arguing about eligibility. The statutory definition is explained in Planning Geek’s Part 20 definitions guide. Address numbering is relevant evidence, but it is not a substitute for understanding the physical building.

One extra storey would dominate Burnell Road

The Inspector regarded additions to Blocks A and B, C and D as broadly acceptable in terms of their external appearance. Those buildings sit back from surrounding streets, and their increased height would usually be seen through gaps between other buildings. Site levels, existing four-storey accommodation nearby and the generous spacing between the blocks would help absorb their increased scale.

Block E was different. It faces Burnell Road, where neighbouring buildings generally share a relatively consistent height, with taller buildings at some road junctions. An extra storey on its prominent roof would create an abrupt rise in the middle of the row and draw attention to a distinctively shaped roof above adjoining properties.

The Inspector considered that this would cause substantial harm to the streetscene, despite matching materials and aligned windows. Taller buildings elsewhere in Sutton did not remedy the relationship with the immediate surroundings. The rooftop flats appeal therefore failed the external appearance requirement under paragraph A.2(1)(e) for Block E.

That distinction matters when packaging a multi-block rooftop proposal. A satisfactory addition to one block does not automatically make another acceptable. Particular elevations, nearby rooflines, viewpoints and the street’s local rhythm must be considered individually, even though the permission route is a national permitted development class.

Elevated windows would overlook private gardens

Privacy presented an independent difficulty. New habitable-room windows in the upper floors of Blocks A and B would look towards rear gardens on Oakhill Road. The Inspector identified around 16 metres between the new rear elevation and the boundary of those gardens, with the extra two rows of windows providing elevated views that existing fences and outbuildings could not screen.

The decision described the result as an unacceptable sense of surveillance. Some overlooking already existed in the neighbourhood, but the proposed openings would be higher, and occupants might spend prolonged periods beside windows serving living accommodation. The existing degree of intervisibility was therefore not sufficient justification for more intrusion.

The situation at Block E and neighbouring 15 Burnell Road was assessed differently. Views from its proposed rear windows would be oblique, and smaller side windows serving non-habitable spaces could, if necessary, have been obscured by condition. The problem was therefore specific to the garden relationship at Oakhill Road, not every additional window in the scheme.

For the rooftop flats appeal, the unacceptable impact on privacy engaged paragraph A.2(1)(g). The Inspector had regard to local and London Plan policies only so far as they helped assess the statutory prior approval issues, and did not treat general density targets or housing delivery benefits as reasons to overlook the identified harm.

A second appeal about bin stores also failed

A related appeal, reference 6012096, had been dismissed separately on 12 November 2026. It concerned the proposed erection of bin and cycle stores. The Inspector was satisfied with the cycle stores but found that the new bin store near an existing flat could cause noise disturbance, particularly from deposited glass and collections, together with potentially significant odours from spilled or overflowing waste.

That separate decision was not itself the ruling on whether additional storeys met Class A. It does, however, underline how ancillary facilities can generate their own planning problems, particularly when extra dwellings add pressure to an already occupied block. The two appeal decisions must not be conflated.

The developer had also submitted a unilateral undertaking restricting future occupiers’ eligibility for controlled parking zone permits. This resolved a separate council concern about transport impacts. The remaining objections concerned specific physical and residential amenity effects that could not be repaired by the parking undertaking.

What rooftop developers should take from Sutton

Developers should first establish the building’s physical and lawful characteristics, then test each prior approval consideration with the same care as a detailed planning submission. Street-level views, roof profiles and three-dimensional overlooking analysis are especially important where substantial new accommodation would sit above existing homes.

An approach that treats all buildings in one red-line boundary as interchangeable is risky. The Inspector differentiated between blocks that could accommodate more height and one that would cause unacceptable visual harm, and between neighbouring properties with materially different privacy relationships.

The rooftop flats appeal is appeal 6012081, dated 18 November 2026. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase. The Planning Inspectorate record provides the official reference, while appeal 6012096 concerns the separate bin and cycle stores, with its official record on the Planning Inspectorate’s appeal service. The quoted passages above are from the Inspector’s decision under the Open Government Licence.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Affected by this story, or spotted something we should check? Report an issue with this article

Planning news by email

Get the latest Planning Geek stories in one daily digest.

Finding Planning Geek useful?
Buy Ian a coffee to say thanks

Media enquiries

Journalist, broadcaster or producer? Need a quick comment on a planning story, policy change or decision?

Request a comment →

YouTube

Planning Geek on YouTube

Watch Ian explain permitted development, use classes, planning applications and current planning changes.

Watch on YouTube

Latest planning news