Green Belt redevelopment has been allowed at Bricket Wood in Hertfordshire, with an Inspector granting outline planning permission for nine homes on land containing a builder’s yard and other existing development. The St Albans appeal decision, issued on 19 November 2026, turns on the current test for previously developed land rather than an assertion that all brownfield land can be built on.
Inspector E Everitt allowed appeal 6012997 at Carpenters Workshop off Lye Lane, overturning St Albans City Council’s refusal of application 5/25/1762. Access, layout and landscaping were before the Inspector, while appearance and scale are reserved for later approval. The permission is subject to conditions, and it is not an unrestricted consent for any design of nine houses.
The Green Belt redevelopment decision is useful because the commercial yard’s full lawfulness had not been conclusively established. The Inspector nevertheless identified an existing lawful dwelling and its developed curtilage. The decision then considered whether replacing that development with housing would cause substantial harm to openness, and separately examined the safety and accessibility of the private access road.
Green Belt redevelopment and the lawful land question
The site lies outside a defined settlement, in an area of woodland, open fields and dispersed development between Bricket Wood and How Wood. It had been used as a builder’s and haulage yard, with ancillary structures, hardstanding, containers and tanks. A separate certificate of lawfulness application covering those activities was still before the council when the appeal was decided.
That unresolved certificate did not automatically mean that no part of the site was previously developed. The Inspector was satisfied that a lawful dwelling existed within the appeal site and considered the curtilage of its lawful developed area. On the evidence of this particular case, this was sufficient to regard the site as previously developed land (PDL). It does not certify every commercial activity or structure in the yard as lawful.
Under policy GB7(1)(e) of the August 2026 National Planning Policy Framework, Green Belt redevelopment of previously developed land can be treated as not inappropriate where it would not cause substantial harm to openness. The policy route matters. The Inspector did not need to decide that this was grey belt under the separate test in GB7(1)(g), nor to find very special circumstances. Our guide to previously developed land explains the distinction between the land’s status and the consequences for development.
Why the openness impact did not defeat nine homes
There was no attempt to pretend that nine homes would have no effect. The Inspector accepted that the proposed footprint would expand considerably and domestic gardens and other paraphernalia would erode spatial and visual openness. The site also contributes to the separation between Bricket Wood and How Wood.
The assessment was nevertheless specific to the site’s existing character. Lawful buildings already formed part of a more developed stretch of the access road. Established woodland and vegetation screened the yard from much of the wider area, and the landscaping scheme would provide further screening once established. The contribution made by this particular parcel to wider Green Belt openness was considered limited.
The Inspector concluded that “the harm which would result from the proposal would not be of such a scale that it would be substantial”. That finding brought the proposal within the GB7(1)(e) exception, despite acknowledged harm. A different footprint, less screening or a less developed site could produce a different outcome. Green Belt redevelopment is a site-specific assessment, not a permission to replace any yard with homes.
A narrow private road and no continuous footway
The other central objection concerned the route from the site to local services. The access is a relatively narrow private road leading to Lye Lane, with no formal pavements, cycle lanes or street lighting along significant stretches. Some future residents would find walking and cycling inconvenient, particularly during the winter or after dark.
However, the site is within walking and cycling distance of services at Bricket Wood, and relatively close to bus stops and Bricket Wood railway station. The Inspector observed forward visibility, informal places for pedestrians to seek refuge and an informal footway along the verge connecting to formal facilities farther along the route. Other existing homes use similar routes.
Importantly, the highway concerns were not supported by substantive evidence that the road could not accommodate the additional residential traffic safely. The Inspector found the scheme consistent with the relevant accessibility policies and did not require works on land outside the appellants’ control. For Green Belt redevelopment, the mere absence of an ideal footway is not necessarily enough to establish an unacceptable safety impact, although the details will vary between appeals.
The permission has important conditions
The outline permission leaves appearance and scale for subsequent reserved matters applications. It also requires a construction traffic management plan, noise protection for future homes because of the nearby M25, investigations and remediation relating to contamination, and suitable surface-water drainage within a groundwater Source Protection Zone.
Ecological and landscape safeguards are also detailed. These include protected-species checks, a construction environmental management plan, measures for bats, swifts and hedgehogs, tree and hedge protection and the agreed landscape planting. The Inspector noted that the statutory biodiversity gain plan requirement applies and did not duplicate it with a further planning condition.
The council will still assess the reserved matters, while the conditions and biodiversity requirements impose obligations before and during construction. Green Belt redevelopment succeeding at appeal does not remove those later approvals, discharge requirements or environmental responsibilities. The decision is an outline approval, not a finding that every construction detail has already been settled.
Why the decision matters for other sites
This case illustrates two tasks that should not be conflated. First, establish the lawful development and the extent of land that falls within PDL. Second, assess the actual spatial and visual openness effects of what is proposed. A site can qualify as previously developed and still fail GB7(1)(e) if the harm to openness is substantial.
It is also a reminder to test transport objections against real distances, the character of surrounding routes and the evidence of risk. A policy preference for sustainable transport does not by itself resolve whether the specific proposed homes would create an unacceptable highway safety impact. Our Green Belt and grey belt guidance sets the separate routes out in more detail.
The Green Belt redevelopment appeal was allowed on 19 November 2026 under reference 6012997. The Planning Inspectorate’s case record gives the appeal reference and decision, and the appeal decision is also available on AppealBase. It should be read against the September 2026 St Albans Local Plan and August 2026 Framework considered by the Inspector.


0 Comments