A Stockport costs award has followed the approval of a proposed convenience store in Offerton after an Inspector found that Stockport Council unreasonably refused permission over vehicle servicing and parking. The council must pay the developer’s appeal costs, although the amount remains to be agreed or assessed.
Inspector Katie McDonald allowed Aim Capital Limited’s planning appeal on 16 November 2026 and separately made a full award of costs against Stockport Metropolitan Borough Council. The proposal would replace a car repair garage and MOT centre on Marple Road with a neighbourhood retail shop, parking and revised vehicle access.
The Stockport costs award matters beyond this development because the Inspector said a servicing management plan could address the highway objections through a planning condition. She also found that the council had treated a comparable Co-op development differently. The case illustrates why a planning refusal needs convincing evidence rather than speculation about whether routine delivery controls could be difficult to enforce.
Stockport costs award: why the council lost
The appeal concerned planning application DC/095317, proposing to demolish existing garage and MOT testing premises and build a Class E(a) convenience store. The site is on the south side of Marple Road in Offerton. The retail building would stand towards the rear of the plot, with customer parking and revised access towards the road.
Stockport refused the application largely because it considered deliveries could not be carried out safely. The council was concerned about goods vehicles reversing onto or off the highway, temporary closure of parking bays during unloading and overspill parking on neighbouring streets. It did not accept that operational restrictions would adequately control those risks.
Aim Capital’s case rested on a Servicing Management Plan (SMP), which had already been before the council when it refused the application, together with detailed vehicle tracking. The access arrangement would widen the north-western entrance, close two others and provide thirteen parking spaces. The Inspector concluded that the access and servicing measures would protect highway safety and satisfy the relevant Stockport planning policies.
The Stockport costs award was a separate decision from the grant of planning permission. For costs, the Inspector had to find unreasonable behaviour that caused unnecessary appeal expense. She found the council had rejected a workable planning condition and handled a comparable retail development inconsistently.
How servicing and parking would work
The proposed store would be serviced by a ten-metre rigid goods vehicle, entering the site forwards, reversing into the loading bay and leaving forwards. Swept-path drawings addressed that lorry and a larger 11.32-metre vehicle. That evidence enabled the Inspector to assess the actual manoeuvres rather than assume that deliveries required reversing in the road.
The plan anticipated approximately four goods vehicle deliveries and two van deliveries each day, outside the busiest shopping periods. Staff would temporarily reserve six parking bays for vehicle manoeuvres, but two would be released once the initial reversing movement was completed. Nine spaces would be available while the lorry unloaded.
The council’s own highway consultee considered eight parking spaces adequate for a store of this scale. With nine remaining during unloading, the Inspector was not persuaded that deliveries would displace so many cars as to create an unacceptable highway danger. She also considered the short visits typical of convenience-store customers and the site’s bus connections.
The council feared that lorries might arrive from the wrong direction or that a future retailer might not follow the plan. The Inspector accepted that enforcement of vehicle routes could be difficult but considered the SMP capable of being secured by condition. The Stockport costs award turned partly on the council’s unreasonable refusal to rely on that familiar planning mechanism.
Why the full costs award was made
The separate Stockport costs award records the developer’s argument that highway matters could be controlled through conditions and that a comparable scheme had been treated differently. Inspector McDonald accepted both points. Her costs decision stated: “The failure to impose the condition and permit the development was unreasonable behaviour.”
Servicing management plans are commonly required by conditions for urban commercial developments. The Inspector considered that if a future operator wanted different arrangements, it could seek a variation of the condition. Monitoring delivery routes might require enforcement work, but that possibility did not make the condition incapable of working.
The appellant also highlighted a Co-op store at Great Moor, where parking was more constrained and vehicle servicing was restricted. The council had imposed and discharged an SMP condition for that development only two weeks before deciding a similar condition would not suffice at Marple Road. The Inspector found this inconsistency amounted to further unreasonable behaviour.
The council’s approach had caused the developer to incur avoidable appeal expenses. A full costs order was made in Aim Capital’s favour, but no monetary figure was specified. The amount must be agreed or assessed by the Senior Courts Costs Office. Planning Geek explains the test in its planning appeal costs guide and the process in its costs recovery guide.
Conditions and traffic restrictions remain important
The Inspector granted planning permission subject to safeguards. Conditions cover servicing, highway works, construction, contamination, drainage, lighting, landscaping and biodiversity. A section 106 obligation dated 1 July 2026 also secures funding and delivery of a traffic regulation order extending double yellow lines across the site frontage to protect visibility and deter obstructive parking.
The traffic controls must be brought into force before the store is occupied. Inspector McDonald considered local objections concerning schoolchildren, bus passengers, older people and other vulnerable road users. She concluded that the proposed access, management arrangements and parking would avoid unacceptable harm to highway safety or traffic flow.
Residents also raised concerns about competition with existing retailers. However, the planning system does not ordinarily protect one shop from another’s commercial competition. The Inspector considered that neighbouring living conditions could be protected by conditions and found no remaining reason to dismiss the appeal.
The Stockport costs award does not free the future occupier from the service plan. It confirms that clear, enforceable management requirements were an appropriate way to make this proposal acceptable, rather than refusing permission based on possible non-compliance.
What councils and applicants can learn
The Stockport costs award shows the financial risk in refusing a scheme on operational grounds without demonstrating why reasonable conditions would fail. Councils can still resist projects where firm evidence establishes dangerous delivery arrangements or harmful parking pressure. The difficulty here was that detailed vehicle tracking, delivery scheduling and parking figures answered the council’s objections.
The Great Moor example was not an automatic precedent requiring approval. It was evidence that the same authority had accepted a servicing condition for a more constrained development. A different conclusion needed an explanation supported by the circumstances of the case.
For applicants, the appeal shows why vehicle dimensions, swept-path analysis, delivery frequency, staff management of parking and enforceable operating plans can be decisive. For councils, the distinction is between a genuine and evidenced highway objection and a manageable risk for which a planning condition is sufficient.
Inspector Katie McDonald issued the planning and full costs decisions on 16 November 2026 under appeal reference 6009262. Both decisions are published on the Planning Inspectorate’s appeal 6009262 page. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase.

0 Comments