Skip to content
Planning Geek logo

Planning consultancyBacked by the UK's leading planning resource

PLANNING NEWS

Dartford storage appeal secures lawful B8 site

An Inspector recognises longstanding Class B8 storage at a Kent farm but restricts the certificate to areas proved lawful.

A Dartford storage appeal has succeeded after a Planning Inspector accepted that three shipping containers, an access track and commercial storage at a Kent farm had become lawful through the passage of time. Inspector R Hitchcock allowed the appeal on 10 November 2026, but reduced the land covered by the certificate to reflect the proven historic use.

The case concerned Hook Green Farm, Hook Green Lane, where The Bex Trust sought a certificate covering Class B8 storage of building materials, scaffolding, tools, plant, vehicles and associated equipment. Dartford Borough Council refused application DA/23/00703/LDC in December 2024, prompting the appeal.

The Dartford storage appeal is particularly useful because it distinguishes an established storage use from a potentially wider builders’ yard. It also demonstrates why the area covered by a lawful development certificate can be smaller than the land originally claimed, even where the core use has been established for many years.

Why the Dartford storage appeal succeeded

The certificate application was made on 5 June 2023 under section 191 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990. The relevant question was whether the storage use had begun at least ten years before that date and had continued without significant interruption. The access track and hardstanding also needed to have been substantially completed at least ten years before that date, a point on which the Inspector referred to Murfitt v Secretary of State for the Environment and the time limits for ancillary operational development. The Inspector assessed these matters on the balance of probabilities.

That is a different exercise from deciding whether the council would grant planning permission for the use today. Planning Geek’s certificate of lawfulness guidance explains how an existing use may become immune from enforcement and why the application date is crucial. The historical period considered in this appeal predated the April 2024 changes to enforcement time limits in England.

Inspector Hitchcock examined dated aerial photographs from 2003 to 2021, photographs from the site and sworn statements by the landowner, business associates and other users. The photographs indicated that the principal containers, access and storage area had been present since at least 2003. Although the later images were only snapshots, the Inspector found that the consistent siting of the containers across them suggested a continuous presence of stored items for ten years or more.

The council acknowledged that sworn declarations received in April 2024 and an additional statement had not been considered in making its refusal. The Inspector took those documents into account on appeal after Dartford had been given the opportunity to comment. The Inspector examined apparent inconsistencies in the dates given, but considered that these were partly explained by changes in the businesses operating on the land.

Was the land a builders’ yard or Class B8 storage?

The most interesting issue in the Dartford storage appeal was the description of the premises as a builders’ yard in some of the witness evidence. That phrase can indicate a composite operation involving fabrication, maintenance or offices, rather than storage alone. Dartford questioned whether the evidence supported the narrower use named in the application.

The Inspector observed that a builders’ yard would generally be interpreted as something entailing more than storage alone. However, the statements described storage of goods, tools and vehicles. On visiting the site, the Inspector found the containers and infill areas being used for storage, with little evidence of a main administrative or workshop function.

One third party referred to workspace and office use, but this was not supported sufficiently to displace the broader evidence for commercial storage. Inspector Hitchcock concluded that the established activity was Class B8 storage, including the hardstanding, access and containers used for the purpose.

Planning Geek’s Use Class B8 guide explains that the storage of a business’s own materials or vehicles can be a storage use, rather than requiring the operator to run a commercial warehouse for other customers. The Dartford storage appeal illustrates why labels used by neighbours or businesses do not necessarily define the planning use.

Why not all the land was certified

The aerial images did not support every part of the area on the application plan. A southern projection of claimed hardstanding was unclear in 2003 and appeared to have naturalised in later images. A levelled area north of the shipping containers was apparently more recent. Evidence of sufficiently frequent and consistent use of some eastern land was also weak.

The Inspector amended the plan to include only those areas where the required period of storage use or operational works was established. This was not a technicality: a certificate defines the use and land that have been proved lawful, and reliance on it later depends upon the precise wording and attached plan.

The Dartford storage appeal was therefore allowed but not as an unrestricted validation of the entire original application boundary. The main Class B8 storage site was accepted, while less well-evidenced extensions fell outside the certificate. Landowners who expand a commercial yard in phases need date-specific records for each enlargement, not just evidence about the original yard.

Neighbours raised concerns about traffic, flooding, rural character and the Green Belt. Those matters may be important to a planning application, but the Inspector noted that planning merits are not considerations in a section 195 appeal. The Inspector’s job was to determine whether the specified existing use was lawful, not to judge its planning merits.

Practical significance and decision details

The appeal highlights the value of historic aerial evidence, photographs, statements from former occupiers and accurate plans. A council should consider all relevant evidence, while an applicant should not assume a general claim of long occupation automatically proves every activity or part of a site.

The Dartford storage appeal was determined by Inspector R Hitchcock on 10 November 2026, reference APP/T2215/X/25/3360014. The application reference was DA/23/00703/LDC. The Planning Inspectorate case record identifies the appeal. The appeal decision is also available on AppealBase.

The relevant legal provisions are section 191 and section 195 of the 1990 Act. Anyone relying on this decision should note the difference between established Class B8 storage and a materially different or more intensive builders’ yard.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Affected by this story, or spotted something we should check? Report an issue with this article

Planning news by email

Get the latest Planning Geek stories in one daily digest.

Finding Planning Geek useful?
Buy Ian a coffee to say thanks

Media enquiries

Journalist, broadcaster or producer? Need a quick comment on a planning story, policy change or decision?

Request a comment →

YouTube

Planning Geek on YouTube

Watch Ian explain permitted development, use classes, planning applications and current planning changes.

Watch on YouTube

Latest planning news

Liverpool HMO appeal: full costs award

Liverpool HMO appeal: full costs award

An Inspector allows two Liverpool HMOs and awards full appeal costs after finding the council’s noise objections inadequately supported.

Rural leisure appeal fails on highways

Rural leisure appeal fails on highways

Three farm barns proposed for sports and recreation fail at appeal over rural road safety and missing biodiversity information, despite acceptable Green Belt impacts.