Skip to content
Planning Geek logo

Planning consultancyBacked by the UK's leading planning resource

PLANNING NEWS

Water tower appeal fails Class R agricultural test

A Hampshire water tower failed its Class R agricultural-use test despite a claimed historic farming connection and a council officer's earlier email.

A water tower appeal in Hampshire has been dismissed after an Inspector found that a historic rural tower had not been proved eligible for commercial conversion under Class R permitted development rights. The decision concerns a timber-clad water tower at Goodworth Clatford, near Andover, and a claimed Class E(g)(iii) industrial use.

Inspector Grahame J Kean issued his decision on 16 November 2026, upholding Test Valley Borough Council’s refusal to grant a certificate of lawful use or development. The owner relied heavily on a council officer’s email from 2020 acknowledging an agricultural use, but that correspondence was not a formal certificate and did not establish the conditions required by Class R.

The water tower appeal illustrates why past council advice, the history of a building and its actual agricultural use must be examined separately. An earlier enforcement decision had also been overlooked by the parties. A separate application for costs against the council was refused.

Why the water tower appeal concerned Class R

The building stands in a field near the village church. It was said to have been erected in 1936 to supply water to surrounding agricultural land. The applicant, Joe Li, sought a certificate under section 191 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990, arguing that a use within Class E(g)(iii) for industrial processes had begun in February 2024.

Test Valley refused application 25/00399/CLEN in June 2025. The applicant then appealed under section 195 of the 1990 Act. Unlike an ordinary planning appeal, this required the Inspector to determine whether the development was lawful on the evidence at the relevant time, rather than whether the proposed industrial activity would be a good idea in planning terms.

Class R of Part 3 of Schedule 2 to the General Permitted Development Order 2015 can authorise the conversion of qualifying agricultural buildings to certain commercial uses. It is not a universal right to convert any old rural building. The Planning Geek guide to Class R explains the eligible uses, agricultural history and procedural requirements.

The required agricultural history was missing

The water tower appeal turned on whether the structure had been used solely for agricultural purposes as part of an established agricultural unit at the required date. Broadly, Class R examines use on 3 July 2012, the last agricultural use in certain cases where a building had already fallen out of use, or a qualifying ten-year period where agricultural use began after that date.

The Parish Council referred to the tower’s historic agricultural function, including a pump and well which it said could still operate. There were also references to its use as a water tower in 2006. But this historical context did not establish the relevant planning use at the qualifying dates or identify an agricultural holding with which the building was connected.

The council’s earlier records described the tower as unused and surrounded by overgrown scaffolding. A claim that water had been supplied to a nearby golf club was later corrected after the owner disputed it. Inspector Kean was not satisfied that a sufficiently precise account had been provided of the tower’s actual agricultural use or when it last occurred.

A rural building can have an agricultural appearance or history without meeting the statutory requirements for agricultural permitted development. Our guide to agricultural land use explains why the facts about an actual farming operation matter.

Why an officer’s 2020 email was not conclusive

The applicant relied on an email sent in May 2020 by a senior planning officer. The officer had apparently been told that a proposed change of use was not implemented and responded that “the lawful use of the tower remains agricultural”. The appellant regarded this as a council acknowledgement of the tower’s lawful agricultural status.

However, the earlier message from the planning agent was not included in the evidence, so the context of the response was incomplete. More fundamentally, the Inspector found that a planning officer’s informal statement could not itself determine the statutory lawfulness of the use. It did not amount to a formal certificate under the 1990 Act.

The Inspector referred to Flattery and Japanese Parts Centre Ltd v Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government and Nottinghamshire County Council [2010] EWHC 2868 (Admin). That High Court judgment confirms the limited legal effect of informal officer advice where statutory lawfulness must be established through the proper procedures.

In the water tower appeal, the Inspector concluded that the information was “insufficiently precise” to demonstrate the agricultural use needed to qualify for Class R on the balance of probabilities. A helpful email might be part of the evidence, but it could not fill the gaps in the agricultural history.

Abandonment was raised, not definitively decided

The prolonged apparent lack of activity raised a separate issue. A lawful agricultural use might, in some circumstances, have been abandoned if the building had ceased to serve that purpose for a sufficiently substantial period. The Inspector referred to that possibility after considering the planning history.

But the water tower appeal did not turn on a positive finding that agricultural use had been abandoned. The Inspector expressly said it was unnecessary to resolve the question because the applicant had not proved the initial Class R qualifying conditions in the first place. Failure to establish the alleged use is not the same as proving that an established use was abandoned.

Planning Geek’s guide to abandonment of a planning use sets out the considerations that may be relevant where a historic use has stopped. A long gap in activity should prompt careful research, rather than an automatic assumption about the present lawful use.

An earlier enforcement appeal had been overlooked

Another unusual feature was the Inspector’s observation that neither party had referred to two related enforcement appeals decided in March 2020. They concerned gravel hardstanding around the water tower and resulted in the enforcement notice being upheld, requiring the land to be restored with grass and wildflowers.

That earlier Inspector had also identified a lack of evidence about occupation or business use of the tower. Those observations were potentially relevant to the later certificate claim, even though the earlier enforcement proceedings concerned different alleged development.

The water tower appeal therefore demonstrates why searching the full planning and appeal history is important before submitting a certificate application. Relevant factual findings may appear in an old Inspector’s decision rather than in the latest application papers or correspondence with the council.

The separate costs application failed

The owner sought a full award of costs against Test Valley Borough Council, alleging unreasonable conduct because the council had previously accepted agricultural use and then challenged it. The Inspector dismissed that application in a separate decision issued on the same date.

He found that the council had made reasonable enquiries, checked the available history and reached a rational decision on the evidence. The burden remained with the applicant to demonstrate lawfulness on the balance of probabilities. A disagreement about the significance of the 2020 email did not establish unreasonable behaviour causing unnecessary appeal expense.

Neither the certificate appeal nor the costs claim succeeded. The outcome should not be read as a general prohibition on converting old water towers. It illustrates the importance of proving the actual qualifying use before relying on a specific permitted development right.

Inspector Grahame J Kean dismissed appeal APP/C1760/X/25/3368292 on 16 November 2026. The decision and the separate costs ruling are also available on AppealBase.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Affected by this story, or spotted something we should check? Report an issue with this article

Planning news by email

Get the latest Planning Geek stories in one daily digest.

Finding Planning Geek useful?
Buy Ian a coffee to say thanks

Media enquiries

Journalist, broadcaster or producer? Need a quick comment on a planning story, policy change or decision?

Request a comment →

YouTube

Planning Geek on YouTube

Watch Ian explain permitted development, use classes, planning applications and current planning changes.

Watch on YouTube

Latest planning news

College Bank demolition for 600 homes

College Bank demolition for 600 homes

Rochdale’s Seven Sisters are earmarked for demolition and around 600 replacement homes, but planning permission has not yet been granted.